IN THE NATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COURT OF NIGERIA

IN THE LAGOS JUDICIAL DIVISION

HOLDEN AT LAGOS

 

BEFORE HIS LORDSHIP:                                  HON. JUSTICE M. N. ESOWE

 

DATE: MARCH 30, 2023                                   SUIT NO.: NICN/LA/145/2021

 

BETWEEN

MR ARUNA COLLINS EKPEN                                           CLAIMANT

 

AND

LAPO MICROFINANCE BANK LIMITED                         DEFENDANT

 

REPRESENTATION

Sylvester Ijie, Esq for the Claimant.

Teena Wills-Obong, Esq for the Defendant.

 

JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

1.      The Claimant was employed by the Defendant on 02.12.2013. His employment was confirmed on 21.10.2015 vide a letter of confirmation dated the same day. In the course of his employment with the Defendant, the Claimant worked in various capacity, and was placed on a monthly salary of N92,775.90. The Defendant transferred the Claimant to one of its branch office at Obalende Nigeria from the Defendant’s Opebi branch. The Claimant alleges he was not paid relocation allowance, due to the distance from his place of residence to the Defendant’s Forsyth branch. He had challenges with keeping up with his daily resumption time. The Defendant placed restrictions on the Claimant’s salary account and on 09.12.2020 it disengaged the Claimant from its employment.

 

2.      The Claimant vide a General Form of Complaint and his Statement of Claimant filed on 21.03.2021 seeks the following against the Defendant:

 

a)     A DECLARATION that the purported dismissal of the employment of the Claimant is unfair, unlawful and in breach of the principles of fair hearing and international best practices on labour law.

b)    A DECLARATION that the withholding of the Claimant’s salaries for three consecutive months is unlawful, unjustified and done with utmost bad faith.

c)     AN ORDER of this Honourable Court directing the Defendant to pay the Claimant the total sum of N278,327.73 (Two Hundred and Seventy-eight Thousand, Three Hundred and Twenty-seven Naira, Seventy-three Kobo) being the unpaid salaries for three months at N92,775.90 (Ninety-two Thousand, Seven Hundred and Seventy-five Naira, Ninety Kobo) per month owed to the Claimant.

d)    Interest on the sum of N278,327.73 (Two Hundred and Seventy-eight Thousand, Three Hundred and Twenty-seven Naira, Seventy-three Kobo) at the rate of 21% on the principal sum till judgment is delivered and interest at the rate of 10% on the judgment sum from the day of judgment of this Honourable Court till the judgment sum is fully liquidated.

e)     General damages in the sum of N1,000,000.00 (One Million Naira only) for unfair dismissal, unlawful and unjustified termination of contract, financial hardship and socio-economic discomfort suffered by the Claimant because of the Defendant’s refusal to release the Claimant’s arrears of salary for 3months despite repeated demands.

f)      Cost of this action as assessed by the Honourable Court.

 

3.      TRIAL

4.      Hearing commenced on 18.11.2021 with the Claimant testifying as CW1, he adopted his witness statements on oath as his evidence in chief and through him eleven (11) documents were tendered in evidence, admitted and marked as exhibits C1-C11 respectively. CW1 was cross-examination after which he closed his case. On behalf of the Defendant, one Idemudia Mavis Osayomore, a Credit analyst testified as DW1, he adopted his witness statement on oath and through him, a total of nine (9) documents were tendered in evidence, admitted and marked as exhibits D1 – D9 respectively. DW1 was cross-examined following which the matter was adjourned to enable parties file and exchange their respective final written addresses.

 

5.      DEFENDANT’S FINAL WRITTEN ADDRESS

6.      In its final written address filed on 08.09.2022 with leave of Court, the Defendant formulated two (2) issues for determination, namely:

 

7.      Whether the Claimant’s appointment was lawfully terminated in line with the procedure stated in the Defendant’s condition of service and terms of employment and principles of international best practices on labour law.

8.      Whether the Claimant is entitled to the relief of money claimed and damages for the termination of his employment.

 

9.      On issue one, Learned Defence Counsel submitted that the Claimant gave controverted evidence that his employment was not terminated in line with the condition of service which regulate the contract between the parties. Parties are bound by the terms of their Agreement – UBN Plc v Soares (2012) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1312) 554. A witness cannot give contradictory evidence on material facts. An employer can terminate a contract of employment with the employee at any time in keeping with the terms of the employment – Olaniyan & Ors v Unilag (1985) LPELR-2868(SC). Counsel on issue two contended that the Claimant’s evidence on the restriction of his account and unpaid salaries was controverted under cross-examination and the Court is not a father Christmas to grant a claim not supported by credible evidence. The Defendant urged the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s suit with substantial cost.

 

10. CLAIMANT’S FINAL WRITTEN ADDRESS

11. Reacting to the Defendant’s final written address, the Claimant filed his final written address on 18.10.2022 wherein he formulated two (2) issues for determination, to wit:

 

12. Whether the Claimant has not made out a case to be entitled to the prayers sought in this matter.

13. Considering the facts of this case, whether the Claimant is not entitled to interest and damages.

 

14. Claimant’s Counsel argued on issue one that the Claimant has cogently proven with documentary evidence and uncontroverted facts that his employment as wrongfully terminated. Where a specific provision is contained for termination in an employment contract, both parties are bound to adhere strictly to the express terms of such provision. The Defendant did not issue the required notice termination the Claimant’s employment in line with clause 8 of the employment contract, making the said termination wrongful – Katto v CBN (1999) 6 NWLR (Pt. 607) 390 at 405, B-C. The failure by the Defendant to give the requisite notice or make payment in lieu contemporaneously makes the termination of the employment wrongful. A community reading of Sections 15 and 5 of the Labour Act shows that the Defendant cannot withhold the salaries of the Claimant when same is due and payable.

 

15. On the documents and the additional list of documents filed by the Defendant on 18.03.2022, Counsel submitted that the documents were procured while this proceeding was pending so they are inadmissible and should be discountenance – Section 83(3) of the Evidence Act, 2011, Nwaegiu v Akuma (2013) 17 NWLR (Pt. 1364) 117. Canvassing arguments on issue two, Counsel contended that having established that the Claimant’s employment was wrongfully terminated and there was restriction on his salary account without just cause, the Claimant is entitled to damages – Ihezukwu v Unilag (1990) NWLR (Pt. 146) 598. Award of damages has been the most applicable remedy in cases of breach of contract like this.

 

16. DEFENDANT’S REPLY ON POINT OF LAW

17. In response to issues raised in the Claimant’s final written address, the Defendant filed a Reply on Points of Law on 02.11.2022 where it reiterated its position that in a master-servant relationship, the employer can terminate the contract according to its terms whenever it wants – Garuba v Kwara Investment Co. Ltd (2005) 5 NWLR (Pt. 917) 160. An employment can be terminated without reason – Asheik v Governor of Borno State (1994) 2 NWLR (Pt. 326) 344. Parties are bound by the terms of their agreement. In relation to exhibit D10, Claimant’s Counsel did not object to its admissibility when it was been tendered. The Claimant has failed to provide legal basis for the grant of the reliefs as contained on his originating processes.

 

 

 

18. RESOLUTION

19. Having regards to the circumstances of this suit, the processes filed, the evidence adduced and the various submissions of Counsel on both sides, this Court distils the issue below for determination, namely:

 

20. In the light of the evidence before the Court, has the Claimant discharged the burden of proof on him to entitle him to the reliefs sought.

 

21. The Claimant’s suit is founded on the contract of employment with the Defendant and in civil cases the burden of proof lies on him who asserts to adduce credible, cogent and sufficient evidence to establish what he asserts to be in existence – Section 131 of the Evidence Act, 2011. The Claimant has to prove his case on the balance of probabilities or on the preponderance of evidence by producing credible evidence, documentary and or oral to establish his claims. See Obe v MTN Nig Comm. Ltd (2021) 18 NWLR (Pt. 1809) 415. Some of the Claimant’s claims seek declaratory pronouncements and such claims are usually not granted as a matter of course or on admission by the Defendant or even in the default of a defence, they require the Claimant to adduce cogent, credible evidence to establish his entitlement to such reliefs. See Okoye v Nwankwo (2014) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1429) 95, Chukwuma v Shell Petroleum (Nig) Ltd (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt. 289) 512.

 

22. Learned Counsel to the Claimant raised a preliminary issue of law as touching the admissibility of exhibit D10 (fund transfer form and certificate of compliance filed on 17.02.2022) given the fact that it was made during the pendency of this proceedings contrary to Section 83(3) of the Evidence Act, 2011. Defence Counsel in response argues that the Claimant did not object to the admissibility of exhibit D10 while it was being tendered besides when a document is relevant to the case at hand it does not matter how it was obtained it can be used in Court. Section 83(3) of the Evidence Act, 2011 provides: “…Nothing in this Section shall render admissible as evidence any statement made by a person interested at a time when proceedings were pending or anticipated involving a dispute as to any fact which the statement might tend to establish.”

 

23. While it is true that relevancy governs the admissibility of documents in civil proceedings, it is not only relevancy that governs admissibility. A piece of evidence may be relevant and still can, by operation of law, be inadmissible. See Kekong v State (2017) 18 NWLR (Pt. 1596) 108. In Ladoja v Ajimobi (2016) 10 NWLR (Pt. 1519) 87 the Supreme Court on the issue of admissibility of document made by person interested when proceedings are pending or anticipated held inter alia: “By Section 83(3) of the Evidence Act, 2011 nothing in the Section shall render admissible as evidence any statement made by a person interested at a time when proceedings were pending or anticipated involving a dispute as to any act which the statement might tend to establish. A document made by a party to a litigation or person interested when proceedings are pending or are anticipated, as in the case at hand, is not admissible…”

 

24. Exhibit D10 was made also a year after this suit was instituted and while proceedings were pending. The Defendant alleges that it was made to controvert the position of the Claimant that the restriction on his salary account with the Defendant still subsists as it revealed that the Claimant made a transfer from the said account to another of his account with Access Bank. As relevant as this piece of evidence may be, and notwithstanding the fact that the Claimant did not object to its admissibility when it was being tendered in evidence, what calls for answer is whether it is admissible before consideration of its probative value may be looked into? The provision of Section 83(3) of the Evidence Act, 2011 are clear and unequivocal they are to be given their plain and natural meaning this to give an interpretation that is consistent with the object and general context of the entire statute.

 

25. On the issue of the failure of the Claimant’s Counsel to object when the document was being tendered, the law is well settled that a trial Court or parties to the suit do not have the power to admit a document that is in no way or circumstance admissible in law. Thus, where a piece of evidence that is inadmissible in law is admitted by a trial Court, Counsel to either party can raise objection to the admissibility of the piece of evidence during final address at the trial. See Haruna v K.S.H.A (2010) 7 NWLR (Pt 1194) 604 at 636, paras. G-D, Ararume v INEC (2007) 9 NWLR (Pt. 1038) 127. Exhibit D10 though relevant was not specifically pleaded by the Defendant, it is my considered view that exhibit D10 has not satisfied all the conditions to make it admissible, I therefore find it inadmissible given the fact that it was made by a party interested during the pendency of this proceedings, it is accordingly marked tendered but REJECTED. I so hold.

 

26. The Claimant’s relief one seeks a declaration that the purported dismissal of the employment of the Claimant is unfair, unlawful and in breach of the principles of fair hearing and international best practices on labour law. Exhibit C6 is the letter of disengagement served or issued to the Claimant terminating his employment with the Defendant. When the issue of wrongful termination of employment is alleged a cardinal consideration of the Court is the terms and conditions of service as contained in the contract of employment. See Umera v NRC (2022) 10 NWLR (Pt. 1838) 349 where the Supreme Court held inter alia: “… A contract of employment is the foundation, the platform and pivot upon which a case for wrongful or unlawful termination of employment by an employee against an employer can be founded or predicated and its success or failure is entirely dependent on the terms and conditions agreed to by the parties in their contract of employment.”

 

27. So, in cases governed only by agreement of parties and not by statute, removal of an employee by termination or dismissal would be in the form and manner agreed to by the parties. Any other form of dismissal or termination connotes wrongful termination or dismissal. See Obanye v UBN Plc (2018) 17 NWLR (Pt.1648) 375 at 390. The dismissal of an employee is not necessarily illegal, unlawful or unconstitutional because it is contrary to the terms of the document governing the relationship between him and his employer. The non-compliance by the employer to the terms of such agreement may result in a wrongful act but a wrongful act is not necessarily an illegal, unlawful or unconstitutional one. An act is wrongful if it involves the infringement of some right. See Ezekwere v Golden Guinea Brew. Ltd (2000) 8 NWLR (Pt. 670) 648 at 658.

 

28. The Claimant has argued that he was not given the required notice terminating his employment with the Defendant and was also not paid contemporaneously in lieu of such notice contrary to the employment contract (Exhibit D1). The Defendant refutes this assertion and insists that the Claimant’s employment was terminated in line with the employment contract. Clause 8 of exhibit D1 is clear as to the conditions surrounding termination of employment, it reads: “The Employer may terminate this Agreement by giving written notice to the Employee as follows: a) with not less than one week’s notice during the first two years of continuous employment, then, b) with not less than a further one week’s notice for each full year of continuous employment after the first two years until the 12th year of continuous employment, and c) with not less than 12 weeks’ notice after 12 years of continuous employment. The Employer may terminate this Agreement without notice or payment in lieu of notice in the case of serious or persistent misconduct such as to cause a major breach of the Employer’s disciplinary rules…”

 

29. The Claimant pleaded and in his evidence in chief testified that he was employed by the Defendant on 02.12.2013 and his appointment was confirmed by the Defendant on 21.10.2015 vide exhibit C1. This means that the Claimant was in continuous employment of the Defendant for seven (7) years and ten (10) months before the termination of his employment. By clause 8(a) and (b) of exhibit D1 (the employment contract), the Defendant is expected to give the Claimant a written notice of six (6) weeks. The Defendant however contends that the Claimant’s employment was terminated owing to his misconduct and by the proviso in clause 8 of the employment contract the Defendant need not give the Claimant any notice before terminating his appointment. The onus is on him who asserts to prove, the Defendant has a burden to establish that the Claimant’s appointment with it was terminated as a result of gross misconduct.

 

30. In an attempt to prove this, the Defendant tendered several queries and a warning letter issued by it to the Claimant (exhibits D2 – D5 respectively). The Defendant for reasons best known to it did not tender in evidence its Staff code of conduct (as included in its first list of documents to be relied upon at trial) or disciplinary rules. This leaves the Court with no contractual footing to define gross misconduct in this context. In simple terms, gross misconduct in the workplace is an act or behavior sufficiently serious to lead to dismissal without notice or payment in lieu of notice. It involves a range of unethical, unprofessional conducts that fall short of the regular workplace standards, including but not limited to gross disregard for the employer. It could be gross negligence, abuse of narcotic substances at workplace, sexual harassment, violence to other staff, dereliction of duty, breach of trust and confidence, stealing just to mention a few.

 

31. In the instant suit, exhibits D2 – D5 the queries issued by the Defendant to the Claimant bothered largely on allegations of lackadaisical, lackluster attitude to work, insubordination, lateness and absence from work, under performance/achievement. I am convinced that queries are not prima facie evidence of the allegations contained therein, rather they are attempts to state certain facts alongside questions seeking answers in order to clear doubts on the said allegations. Exhibit D6 is an internal correspondence of the Defendant directed to the “HOD, CS” informing him or providing an update on the Claimant. With respect, the Claimant cannot absent himself from work in good conscience and turnaround to complain foul. The Claimant has said that the reason he sought for permission to be absent from work for certain number of days in a week was due to the restriction placed on his salary account by the Defendant while this in itself is highly regrettable, the Claimant had a duty to report to his workplace at the appropriate resumption time on each work day.

 

32. Equity however follows the law, the law requires the employer to pay its employees their salaries as and when due upon their discharging their obligations. Though from the content of exhibit D9 (the Claimant’s statement of account on his salary account with the Defendant) indicates that the Defendant made deposits of the Claimant’s salaries but as reflected in exhibits C4 and C4a respectively, the Defendant placed a “debit block” on the said account making it impossible for the Claimant to withdraw his salaries. It is trite that he who seeks equity must do equity, he who comes to equity must come with clean hands. The Defendant cannot, with respect, place a clog in the wheel of the performance of the Claimant and then accuse him of misconduct. Besides, the letter of disengagement did not state that the reason for termination of the Claimant’s appointment was gross misconduct; paragraph one (1) of exhibit C6 (the letter of disengagement) was category that after a review of the Claimant’s performance, the Defendant came to the conclusion that the Claimant had performed below expectation.

 

33. Article 7 of the Termination of Employment Convention, 1982 (No. 158) requires an employer to provide an employee adequate opportunity to defend himself against allegations on conduct and performance before such employee’s employment can be terminated. By Section 7(6) of the National Industrial Court Act the issue of international best labour practice or industrial relation is a question of fact. An employee except for good reasons agreeable by his employer cannot be expected to choose what station the employer elects the employee be posted to work in, an employer is nonetheless expected to pay its employees as and when due, and allow such employees access to their salaries upon payment. There are several disciplinary methods or measures open to an employer where it is of the opinion that an employee deserves to be subjected to discipline but this does not extend to withholding access to the employee’s salary without tangible reason.

 

34. I am of the considered view that the Defendant has not adduce cogent, credible evidence to establish that the Claimant was guilty of gross misconduct to warrant his dismissal without a written notice or payment in lieu of notice. The Defendant therefore had a duty to comply with the provision of clause 8(a) and (b) of the Employment contract by issuing to the Claimant a six (6) weeks written notice terminating his employment or making payment in lieu of such notice. I am thus convinced that the Claimant has adduced credible evidence for the grant in part of relief one (1). Accordingly, it is hereby declared the purported dismissal and or termination of the employment of the Claimant is wrongful and in breach of international best practices on labour law. I so hold.

 

35. The Claimant’s relief two (2) is a declaration that the withholding of the Claimant’s salaries for three consecutive months is unlawful, unjustified and done with utmost bad faith. The Defendant alluded to the fact that in its operation, it is customary for it place a restriction on salary accounts of staff or employees that are laid-off to enable it ascertain and reconcile any outstanding indebtedness to it by such employees. It asserted that the restriction on the Claimant’s salary account was only placed when he was disengaged from its services but exhibits C4 and C4a respectively proves the contrary. The onus was thus on the Defendant to prove the contrary. I have said it before, exhibit D9 (the Claimant’s statement of account) shows the Defendant paid his salary but exhibits C4 and C4a clearly reflects that there was an existence of “all debits blocked” on the said Claimant’s salary account. One then wonders how the Defendant wanted the Claimant to raise funds to transport himself to his workplace each work day, go out for marketing and other ancillary assigned obligations?

 

36. I cannot but agree with the Claimant that the said restriction on his salary account placed by the Defendant was unjustified, unnecessary, wrongful and done in utmost bad faith. Section 5(1) of the Labour Act prohibits an employer from making any deductions or any agreement or contract with its workers for any deductions from the wages to be paid by the employer. Section 15 of the Labour Act mandates that wages shall become due and payable at the end of each period for which the contract is expressed to subsist, be it daily, weekly or at such other period as may be agreed upon. Though from the content of exhibit D9, the Defendant paid the Claimant his salary when it became due and payable, its placing a debit block for three (3) months was in my humble view unconscionable and unlawful.

 

37. The Defendant does not deny that a restriction was placed it only asserts that the restriction was done after the disengagement of the Claimant and was not for long but it did not adduce credible evidence to establish this. There is a difference between withholding and the existence of a restriction, there is no evidence that the Defendant withheld the Claimant’s salaries for three months what the Defendant did was to place a restriction preventing the Claimant from accessing the paid salaries. This Court is of the considered view that the Claimant has adduced cogent, credible evidence in prove of his relief two (2) and same is accordingly granted in the manner stated hereafter. It is hereby declared that the restriction placed on the Claimant’s salaries for three consecutive months by the Defendant is unlawful, unjustified and done with utmost bad faith. I so hold.

 

38. Relief three (3) is for an order directing the Defendant to pay the Claimant his three months salaries at the rate of at N92,775.90 (Ninety-two Thousand, Seven Hundred and Seventy-five Naira, Ninety Kobo) per month. Exhibit D9 shows that the Claimant’s salary for the month of September 2020 was paid on 23.09.2020, that of October and November were paid on 27.10.2020 and 25.11.2020 respectively, for December 2020, the Claimant was not paid his full salary. The burden is therefore on the Claimant to establish that he was not paid his salaries for three months, a burden in my considered view the Claimant failed to discharge. This claim therefore fails and is hereby dismissed. I so hold. Relief four (4) is for interest on the sum awarded in relief three. It is incidental to the grant of relief three. Given the fact that this Court found and held that relief three failed, relief four would also have to fail. See CBN v Okemuo (2018) 15 NWLR [Pt. 1642] 367. I find and hold that the Claimant’s relief four fails and is hereby dismissed. I so find and hold.

 

39. Relief five (5) is for damages for unfair dismissal, unlawful and unjustified termination of contract, financial hardship and socio-economic discomfort suffered by the Claimant because of the Defendant’s refusal to release the Claimant’s arrears of salary for 3months despite repeated demands. The position of our laws before now is that damages claimable in an action for breach of contract of service do not extend to the injured feelings or loss of reputation – Western Nigeria Development Corporation v Abimbola (1966) 1 All NLR 159, Shell Pet. Dev. Co v Lawson-Jack (1998) 4 NWLR (Pt.545) at 272, E. Where a Claimant’s employment is wrongly terminated or dismissed, the only remedy open to the Claimant is a claim for damages for that wrongful termination or dismissal. See Obanye v UBN Plc (supra).

 

40. Exhibit C6 indicates that the Claimant’s appointment was terminated with immediate effect on 09.12.2020. Clause 8(a) and (b) of Exhibit D1 (the employment contract) stipulates that the employee is to be given a week’s written notice for two years of continuous service and a further one week for each year of continuous service. The Claimant worked for the Defendant for seven years and ten months, a week’s notice for the first two years and a further one week notice for each of the remaining five years will amount to six (6) weeks. Meaning that the Claimant ought to have been given six weeks written notice prior to the termination of his employment or payment in lieu of such notice; the Claimant was not paid until sometimes in February 2021 almost three months after his employment was terminated.

 

41. The Claimant has shown that his employment was terminated with immediate effect, and that he was not paid contemporaneously with the issuance of the letter terminating his employment. In NEPA v Isieveore (1997) 7 NWLR (Pt. 511) 135, it was held that when an employment is terminated without giving the required notice, the employer must pay the employee at the time of termination, salary in lieu of notice. See also Chukwumah v Shell Petroleum (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt. 289) 512. That is, the law requires that where a contract of service gives a party a right of termination of the contract by giving a particular length of notice or payment in lieu of the length of notice and the latter is chosen, the party seeking to put an end to the contract must pay to the other party, the salary in lieu of notice at the time of the termination of the contract.

 

42. The Defendant insists that the Claimant by virtue of one of the provisos of clause 8 in the employment contract is not entitled to any written notice or payment in lieu given that he was guilty of gross misconduct. But as stated earlier, the Defendant did not adduce cogent, credible evidence to support this allegation of facts, it means that the evidence adduced by the Claimant on the failure to give him appropriate notice or contemporaneous payment in lieu has not been controverted and can be relied upon by the Court. On this note, I find and hold that the Claimant is entitled to damages for wrongful termination of his employment which would be the amount he ought to have received as payment in lieu of notice, that is, six (6) weeks salary which is N139,163.88 (One Hundred and Thirty-nine Thousand, One Hundred and Sixty-three Naira, Eighty-eight Kobo). Relief five succeeds in part, the sum of N139,163.88 (One Hundred and Thirty-nine Thousand, One Hundred and Sixty-three Naira, Eighty-eight Kobo) representing what the Claimant is entitled to as payment in lieu of notice is awarded as damages against the Defendant in favour of the Claimant. I so hold.

 

43. Relief six (6) is for cost of this suit as assessed by the Court. It is the law that costs follows event. In Yakubu v Min. Housing & Environment, Bauchi State (2021) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1791) 465, it was held inter alia: “cost of an action and cost of filing the action are one and same thing. The general rule is that costs follows event and a successful party is entitled to costs the award or refusal of costs is at the discretion of the Court provided it is exercised judicially and judiciously…” Costs are awarded to indemnify the successful party not as punishment on the party who pays them nor given as a bonus to the party who receives them. In the light of the facts before the Court, this Court is inclined to exercise its discretion in favour of the Claimant and cost is awarded against the Defendant in the sum of N250,000.00 (Two Hundred and Fifty Thousand Naira). I so hold.

 

44. On the whole, this Court finds merit in part of the claims of the Claimant, the issue for determination is resolved in the Claimant’s favour and save as outlined below all other claims and reliefs sought by the Claimant are hereby dismissed. The Court orders as follows:

 

45. IT IS HEREBY DECLARED that the purported dismissal and or termination of the employment of the Claimant is wrongful and in breach of international best practices on labour law.

a)     IT IS HEREBY DECLARED that the restriction placed on the Claimant’s salaries for three consecutive months by the Defendant is unlawful, unjustified and done with utmost bad faith.

b)    The Defendant is ordered to pay the Claimant the sum of N139,163.88 (One Hundred and Thirty-nine Thousand, One Hundred and Sixty-three Naira, Eighty-eight Kobo) as damages representing what the Claimant is entitled to as payment in lieu of notice.

c)     The Defendant is ordered to pay the Claimant the sum of N250,000.00 (Two Hundred and Fifty Thousand Naira) as cost of action as assessed by the Court.

 

46. Judgment is accordingly entered.

 

 

 

Hon. Justice M. N. Esowe, FCIArb

Presiding Judge