IN THE NATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COURT NIGERIA
IN THE ABUJA JUDICIAL DIVISION
HOLDEN AT ABUJA
BEFORE HER LADYSHIP HON. JUSTICE O.A. OBASEKI-OSAGHAE
DATE: SEPTEMBER 29, 2026 SUIT NO: NICN/ABJ/160/2024
BETWEEN
STEPHNNIE ANYAEGBU CLAIMANT
AND
FHI 360 NIGERIA DEFENDANT
REPRESENTATION
Adeola Adedipe SAN for the Claimant, with Samuel Fagade, Isabella Egwaelu, Mark-Anthony Okolocha, Immaculata Obi.
Tosanwumi Opubor for the Defendant, with Fortune Igrubia.
JUDGMENT
Introduction and claims
The Claimant filed this Complaint against the Defendant on June 20, 2024 together with the accompanying processes seeking the following reliefs:
A Declaration that the termination of Claimant’s employment by the Defendant, vide the Separation and Release Letter of 27th July 2023, is wrongful and in breach of the Defendant’s Policies, Directives, Guidelines and work-place regulations.
An Order setting aside the wrongful termination of the Claimant’s employment, as contained in the Separation and Release Letter of 27th July 2023.
An Order against the Defendant, to forthwith compute and pay to the Claimant, all salaries, benefits, emoluments, bonuses and other payments ordinarily accruable to her, from the unlawful separation of 27th July 2023 till date.
The sum of N500, 000, 000. 00 (Five Hundred Million Naira) only, as general damages against the Defendant and N50, 000, 000.00 (Fifty Million Naira) only, as cost of this suit.
Interest on the judgment sum at the rate of 10% per annum from the day of the judgment or such other time the court may direct until the Defendant fully pays or satisfies the said judgment sum to the Claimant.
[2] The Defendant entered appearance on 28th October, 2024 and filed its statement of defence, together with the accompanying processes. The Claimant filed a reply to the statement of defence on 24th January 2025. The matter went to trial.
Case of the Claimant
[3] The Claimant’s on the pleadings is that the Defendant employed her as a Human Resource Officer and discharged her duties in adherence to the Defendant’s policies and guidelines. The Claimant stated that she became a victim of conspiracies, actuated by malice, bad faith and violations of work-place regulations. She stated that on 27th July 2024, the Defendant ended her employment unlawfully, without recourse and adherence to its Policies, Directives, Guidelines and work-place regulations. The Claimant averred that the ground upon which the Defendant predicated the separation letter signed by Iorwakwagh Apera the Country Director was her repeated failure to obey lawful instructions and became effective July 26, 2023.
[4] The Claimant averred that having been subjected to series of mental trauma and emotional distress, she sought legal advice, in consequence of which a formal complaint was made by her Solicitors to the Defendant, on 26th February 2024. The Claimant stated that rather than a careful review of her complaints, the Defendant shabbily responded to the letter and by a wave of hand, forget her labour in the organisation for over 11 years, and continued acting in bad faith thereby justifying the apparent unfairness to her. The Claimant averred that as a result of the outbreak of the COVID-19 virus, the Defendant enacted a policy on telecommuting and remote working which allowed staff to work from home, and maintain a flexible work arrangement. The Claimant averred that she benefited from this because her younger brother who lives with her had to undergo brain surgery, and complications that led to additional 8 surgeries.
[5] The Claimant averred that during this period when she worked from home and had to look after her younger brother, her performance level did not drop, and on 18th January 2023, her role was adjusted upwards by the Defendant, with a salary band increase and a note of appreciation. The Claimant stated that sometime in April 2024, she was informed by telephone by Mr. Audu Amushe, that the remote work policy had been cancelled which he stated was circulated by email of 17th April, 2023. The Claimant stated that she did not receive the email and he forwarded a copy of the email to her. The Claimant stated that given her main roles was the implementation of policies of the organization in Nigeria, she knew that the directive was against the directives of the headquarters in the United States of America, as contained in POL 03036 on Telecommuting and Remote Working, and she immediately drew attention to this anomaly, but none of such was considered. The Claimant stated that sseeing the insistence on cancellation of the remote work operation, she formally applied for a remote work request, directly connected to the exigent care of her younger brother.
[6] The Claimant stated that rather than consider her request on compassionate grounds, and in line with the remote work policy, the Defendant issued her a query on 11th July 2024 signed by her HR Manager Audu Amushe. The Claimant stated that in her response to the query, she noted that Mr. Amushe was conflicted and had personal issues with her, presupposing unfairness, and insincerity of purpose. She also noted in the body of her response, that the compromised stance of Mr. Amushe, was in conjunction with one Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera, who eventually authored the separation letter. The Claimant stated that being a disciplinary procedure activated against her, it was expected that there would be strict adherence to all the rules of procedure and recourse to rights available to her, and that the organization would be interested in the alarm and indictment that she raised in her response, especially as to the fact that Mr Amushe told her on 31st May 2023 that he was under so much pressure to have her removed from work.
[7] The Claimant further stated there was a conspiracy by Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera to ensure she was kicked out of office. The Claimant stated that the Defendant caused the same Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera to write her on 21st of July 2023, stating that her response to the query was unsatisfactory and not successful. The Claimant stated that she had on 19th June 2023 filed a report to Dawn Fisher in the United States, HQ, stating that her mental state was being affected, owing to the unprofessional conducts, violation of ethical workplace conducts and code violations, by Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera. She stated that Mr. Audu Amuse was privy to the malicious behavior of Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera, particularly that he was openly rude to her, repeatedly told her to look for another job, and threatened to beat her up anytime he met her on the street, because he grew up on the street. The Claimant averred that he was neither investigated nor disciplined for violations of FH1360 Code of Ethics and Conduct.
[8] The Claimant stated that it was Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera, who on 21st July 2023 responded to her query responses stating that they were not satisfactory, and thereafter invited her to face a disciplinary panel on the 24th July 2023. The Claimant stated that when she accepted to face the disciplinary panel, she requested to know ahead of time, who the members of the Panel would be, and that no feedback was given to her in this regard, such that could have enabled her to raise objections to the suitability of any member who may have been conflicted at the time. The Claimant averred that the Panel Members who sat over the disciplinary exercise against her, were constituted by Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera. She stated that all the panel members report to him, and no reasonable positive outcome was anticipated from the disciplinary panel, which worked its way to an answer vide the Separation and Release Letter, denying her of an opportunity to fairness. She stated that the termination of her employment was wrongful, prejudicial, and unlawful, for non-compliance with due process already set out in the Defendant’s Policies, Code of Ethics, Directives and Guidelines.
[9] Replying to the defence, the Claimant averred that she was excluded from internal communications regarding workplace resumption. CW averred that although she continued working remotely after being directed to resume physical attendance, t she sought reasonable accommodation due to the urgent care required by her brother following brain surgery, while continuing to satisfactorily discharge her duties. CW stated that her requests for leave and remote work were unreasonably refused contrary to the Defendant's Remote Work Policy. CW stated that she was denied a fair hearing, and was not informed that a decision had been reached in respect of her complaint against Mr Apera. CW stated that the investigation report from Dawn Fisher is contrived, false, and an afterthought, in violation of the Defendant's Professional Conduct Policy and Open Door and No Retaliation Policy. CW stated that no valid disciplinary process preceded her separation, and that the only meeting organized in respect of her separation was the inconclusive virtual meeting which ended due to poor internet connection.
[10] The Claimant (CW) testified in support of her case, and subpoenaed Audu Amushe, (CW2) HR Manager who produced documents admitted in evidence by the and marked Exhibits AA2 to AA17. The Claimant adopted her statements on oath. They were in the exact terms of the pleadings. Under cross-examination, CW informed the court that she was employed by the Defendant as HR Officer, and that part of her job was to ensure compliance with the Defendant’s policies. CW told the court that she worked for the Defendant for about 11 years, and that Mr Audu Amushe was her direct Supervisor. CW stated that she had an official email address and she received group emails. CW confirmed that at the time she was employed, there was no arrangement to work from home; and that she is aware that there is a remote work and telecommuting policy which was activated as a result of the Covid-19 Pandemic. CW stated that during the pendency of the remote work policy for 3 years, she was paid in full and benefitted from the policy. CW denied being aware that by April 2023 Covid-19 had been significantly contained.
[11] CW informed the court that she did not receive the email sent by the Defendant that the remote work and telecommuting policy had been discontinued on April 19, 2003. CW admitted that a copy of the email was forwarded to her by Mr A. Amushe her Supervisor, and stated that she did not resume work when she received the email because the policy qualifies her to work remotely. CW said she did not re-call receiving the email dated 17th May, 2023 from Mr. Amushe informing her that all employees are to resume work physically. CW informed the court that she remembers responding to an email and saying that the new directive will not work for her, and also recalled that Mr Amushe responded that the email is directed to all the staff. CW admitted that she did not resume work in May 2023, and said she doesn’t agree that she was disobeying directives. CW told the court that she sent a sick leave request in June 2023 for 10 days and the application was granted, but she did not resume work after the 10 days leave.
[12] CW told the court she sent a work from home request on 19th June 2023 but did she not resume because she was waiting for a response. CW stated that the Defendant did not tell her to work from home while she was waiting for her response. CW admitted that between April 2023 when the remote work and telecommuting came to an end was two months. CW admitted that she did not resume work physically; and that she received a query on 11th July 2023. CW stated that she responded to the query. CW stated that there was a review panel set up to consider recommendations and she was invited to the meeting which was to be held on 24th July 2023. CW stated that she requested that the meeting be held virtually, but the meeting did not hold virtually or physically; and she received her letter of termination on 27th July 2023.
Case of the Defendant
[13] The Defendant’s case on the pleadings is that the termination of the Claimant's employment was lawful and in compliance with the policies and regulations forming part of her contract of employment. The Defendant averred that it did not act in bad faith against the Claimant, neither was it unfair in terminating her employment based on her consistent refusal to obey lawful directives and instructions. The Defendant averred that it issued a notice to all its staff and employees by email of 19 April 2023 notifying them that it was ending the work from home arrangements that had been in place immediately, and that all employees must report to the office for work. The Defendant stated that the work from home arrangements was necessitated by the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic. The Defendant averred that by April 2023 the Covid-19 had been significantly contained; and its Global Office by an email dated 17 April 2023 issued a directive lifting FHI 360’s Covid-19 requirements effective 19 April 2023.
[14] The Defendant stated that following the directive of its Global Office, the management took the decision that it was safe for its employees to return to the office, and this was communicated to all employees. The Defendant stated that the decision to end the work from home arrangements was a policy and its directive which all employees were required to comply with including the Claimant. The Defendant averred that the Claimant refused to comply with the directive in the email of 19 April 2023 which is a breach of its policy and directive. Notwithstanding this, it continued to pay the Claimant her salaries and other entitlements.
[15] The Defendant averred that in May 2023, the Claimant’s line manager, Mr. Audu Amushe reached out to her by telephone to confirm why she had refused to comply with the directive in the email of 19 April 2023. The Claimant denied receiving the said email. He then forwarded the email to the Claimant on 15 May 2023 and she did not respond until 17 May 2023 when she sent an email to him stating that the new directive will not work for her; and he replied her email stating that this was an organizational directive to all staff. The Defendant averred that the Claimant still refused to return to work, and on 01 June 2023, the Claimant requested for 10 days sick leave effective 01 June 2023 to 14 June 2023 which was granted to allow her attend to her medical needs. The Defendant averred that rather than resume work at the office after the expiration of the sick leave, she sent an email on 19th April to her line Manager requesting for remote working, and continued working from home without any approval from her line manager.
[16] The Defendant averred that by email of 4 July 2023, the Claimant’s line manager sent a follow up email to her to enquire about her health status and if the Claimant is able to work, and she responded that she was well and also able to work. Her line manager subsequently notified the Claimant by email of 7 July 2023 that he was unable to approve her request for remote working and she was again requested to report to the office. The Defendant averred that the Claimant’s actions in failing to resume work at the Defendant’s office amount to gross insubordination and contravention of the Code of Ethics and Conduct. The Defendant stated that on 10 July 2023, the Claimant resumed work at the office but left before the official closing hours without notifying or getting the approval of her supervisor or any member of the management. When asked the reason for leaving the office before closing hours without getting approval, the Claimant said she had technical challenges with her laptop. Upon further enquiry as to whether she informed the technical team to address the technical challenges, she confirmed that she did not.
[17] The Defendant averred that on 11 July 2023, the Claimant was expected to resume work at the office by 8:00 am. However, by 11:31 am, the Claimant was yet to report at the office. As a result, and due to the Claimant’s consistent disobedience of lawful instructions, she was issued a query dated 11 July 2023 that outlined previous requests for her to return to work, which she had not complied with. The Defendant stated that the Claimant responded and did not deny the allegations, rather she attempted to justify why she disobeyed lawful instructions to resume work at the office. The Defendant stated that after submitting her response on 12 July 2023, she failed to return to the office.
[18] The Defendant averred that after a review and consideration of the Claimant’s response, it found the same unsatisfactory and by an email dated 21 July 2023, notified the Claimant of this fact. The Claimant was also informed that the management had recommended a termination of her employment for consistent absence from work and had established a review panel to consider the recommended disciplinary action. The Defendant stated that the Claimant was also informed of the date and time for the panel meeting and was asked to come prepared to the panel meeting with documents that she believes will aid the panel in understanding the situation. The Defendant stated that the review panel meeting was held on 24 July 2023 and at the meeting, the Claimant was afforded a fair hearing, and was unable to satisfactorily justify her consistent absence from work. Consequently, on 27 July 2023, a letter dated the same day was issued to the Claimant terminating her employment.
[19] The Defendant averred that based on the Claimant’s conduct, it was entitled to summarily dismiss her from its employment. Rather, it graciously opted to terminate her employment with full benefits. The Defendant avers that all the terminal benefits and entitlements of the Claimant were duly computed and paid to her in accordance with the terms of her contract of employment. The Defendant stated that the disciplinary procedure activated against the Claimant adhered to all the rules of procedure and had recourse to the Claimant’s right to a fair hearing. The Defendant averred that the Claimant did not at any point request to know the members of the panel , and that all she requested in her email was for the review panel meeting to be virtual and not physical. The Defendant stated that it granted the Claimant’s request and the details of the members of the panel were contained in the virtual panel review meeting invite that was sent to her.
[20] The Defendant further averred that it maintains a zero-tolerance policy for any form of workplace harassment or victimization. The Defendant stated that before the Panel review meeting, Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera had been investigated by the Defendant’s management in respect of the Claimant’s report to Ms. Dawn Fisher (HR Specialist) on 19th June 2023 and he was cleared of any wrongdoing and this fact was duly communicated to the Claimant. The Defendant stated that it complied with clause 1.3 of the Employee Discipline Policy and documented the Claimant’s several infractions and warnings given to her and detailed in her query. The Defendant stated that the termination of the Claimant’s employment is lawful and in compliance with its policies. The Defendant further stated that the Claimant having duly accepted her terminal benefits, has waived the right to institute this action for the alleged wrongful termination of her employment.
[21] Audu Amushe (DW), HR Manager testified for the in support of the Defendant. He adopted his statement on oath. They were in the exact terms of the pleadings. Under cross-examination, DW informed the Court that Mr Iorwakwagh Apera is the Nigerian Office Country Director, and he is also his line manager, and he oversees the HR Unit. DW confirmed that the Claimant lodged a personal complaint against Mr Apera to Dawn Fisher, and that the allegations were investigated by Dawn Fisher. DW stated that there was a feed back to the Clamant and Mr Apera about the outcome of the investigation. DW identified the report (Exhibit D8) and stated that the report was not copied to the Claimant. He said he was not aware the Claimant said she saw the report for the first time in Court. DW told the Court that the Claimant faced a disciplinary panel on 24th July 2023, and that none of the documents he brought to Court contains the minutes or transcripts of the disciplinary session, but that the documents contain the recommendations of the panel Exhibit AA17. DW stated that it is a document of July 21, and the panel session is July 24. DW stated that it is not his evidence that the recommendation pre-dated the panel session and that he does not have a report.
[22] DW confirmed that it is his responsibility and the Defendant’s to document all the disciplinary steps/stages and inform the Claimant; and stated that he did not know if the disciplinary stages were copied to the Claimant. DW told the Court Exhibit D8 was sent directly by Dawn Fisher to his counsel, and that the Code of Ethics Manual prohibits harassment at work and that a report must be made within 24 hours of the violation of the code. DW stated that he was at the meeting where the threats were made, but he did not report it because there was no complaint made to him. DW admitted that he is expected to report a violation once he observes it; and also admitted that he issued the Claimant a query, and in her reply she alleged that he was colluding with Mr Apera to get her out of the office. DW confirmed that there is a policy against retaliation when a concern is reported; and he stated that he acknowledged receipt of the Claimant’s response and told her he would revert back, but it was his Director, Mr. Apera who reverted. DW stated that Mr Apera constituted the disciplinary panel, and that this is the policy of the Defendant.
Final Address
[23] The Defendant’s final address is dated 8th April 2026, and is filed the same day. The Claimant’s final address is dated 28th April, 2026, and is filed the same day. The Defendant’s reply on point of law is filed on the 1st June 2026.
[24] The Defendant submitted four issues for determination as follows:
a) Whether the Claimant is not barred/estopped from instituting this action against the Defendant, having accepted the redundancy/terminal benefits paid to her by the Defendant?
b) Whether in view of the facts and evidence before this Honourable Court, particularly the admissions of the Claimant under cross-examination, the Defendant was justified in terminating the Claimant’s employment on grounds of misconduct and refusal to comply with lawful directives?
c) Whether the Claimant led credible evidence in proof of her claim that the termination of her employment by the Defendant was wrongful and in breach of the Defendant’s policies, directives Guidelines and work-place regulations?
d) Having regard to the pleadings of parties and the evidence before this Honourable Court, whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought?
[24] Learned Counsel arguing issue 1, submitted that the Claimant had expressly and by conduct consented to the termination of her employment and is thereby barred from challenging the termination of her employment. He submitted that having accepted the terminal benefits paid to her, the Claimant has waived her right to claim that her termination was wrongful, and cited Guinness Nigeria Limited v. Mrs Margaret Agoma (1992) 7 NWLR (Pt. 256) 728 at 742; Imperial Medical Centre & Anor v. Ahamefule (2017) LPELR-42886 (CA) at page 35, Shuaibu & Ors v NBC Plc (Coca-Cola) (2020) LPELR-52110 (CA), Ekeagwu v Nigerian Army & Anor (2006) LPELR-7641 at 16 – 17 Para F-F, Ogbondah v Total E & P Nigeria (Unreported) NICN/ABJ/18/2019 judgment delivered on 17th January 2020. He submitted that from the appellate decisions, and the evidence adduced, the Claimant, having duly received her terminal entitlement, made her termination mutual and therefore waived her right against any action for wrongful termination.
[25] Learned counsel argued that the Claimant validly waived her legal right against the Defendant for any claim. He submitted that the law is trite that a person who is sui juris can waive a right conferred upon him by a statute or a contract where the right is for his sole benefit citing Ariori v Elemo (1983) LPELR-552 SC at 21, C&C.B.Dev Co Ltd v Min E.H.&U.D (2019) 5 NWLR (Pt 1666) 485 at 503-504, Bakare v Ogundipe (2021) 5 NWLR (Pt 1768) 1 at 42. He further submitted that the Claimant does not have a reasonable cause of action against the Defendant and that this suit constitutes an abuse of court process as the same was instituted in bad faith and to the irritation and annoyance of the Defendant, and cited Arubo v. Aiyeleru (1993) 3 NWLR (Pt.280) 126 at 142, Saraki v .Kotoye (1992) 9 NWLR (Pt.264) 156 at page 188 – 189.
[25] Learned counsel on issue 2 submitted that the admissions of the Claimant in cross-examination establishes justification for the termination of her employment. He submitted that in a master-servant relationship, the employer retains the prerogative to discipline its employee, including termination of employment, particularly where the employee is guilty of misconduct, insubordination, or refusal to comply with lawful and reasonable directives. He cited Azenabor v. BUK & Anor (2009) LPELR- 8721(CA), Ansambe v B.O.N Ltd (2005) 8 NWLR (pt 928) 650 at 672, Nwobosi v ACB Ltd (1995) 6 NWLR (pt 404) 658 at 686 Para E-F. He submitted that that the Claimant’s persistent refusal to resume work at the office, despite repeated and unequivocal directives, was willful and constitutes clear disobedience and insubordination to the Defendant’s lawful authority. He submitted that the Claimant’s admission that remote working was a temporary measure, and not a term of her employment contract forecloses any suggestion that she possessed a legal or contractual right to insist on working remotely.
[26] Learned counsel submitted that failure to comply with directives constitutes insubordination and gross misconduct, which justifies summary disciplinary action, r Benue Brewery Ltd v. Okonta (2024) LPELR-61878 (CA), Chukwumah v Shell Petroleum (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt 289) 512, University of Calabar v Essien (1996) 10 NWLR (Pt 477) 225, Yusuf v UBN Ltd (1996) 6 NWLR (Pt 457) 632 at 647, UBN Plc v Soares (2012) 11 NWLR (Pt 1312) 550 at 575. He submitted that the Claimant’s termination was done in strict compliance with the Defendant’s policies. It was his submission that the Claimant’s case is anchored on the alleged wrongfulness of her termination, not on any claim of workplace harassment, hostile work environment or victimization arising from her grievance against Mr Apera which the cross-examination of DW centered on, and which is misplaced. He argued that that the internal administrative processes have no bearing on the lawfulness of the Claimant’s termination. He urged the Court to discountenance same.
[27] Learned Counsel on issue 3 and 4 submitted that law is trite that where an employee alleges that the termination of his employment was wrongful, it is the sole duty of the employee to adduce credible evidence to show and establish the terms of the contract of employment that were allegedly violated by the employer, and he cited Wetife v. IGP & Ors (2024) LPELR- 62453(CA), Osoh v CBN (2013) 35 N.L.L.R (Pt 103) 129. He argued that the Claimant has not sufficiently shown how her contract of employment was breached by the Defendant and stated that the regulatory framework governing the employment contract are Exhibit C1, Exhibit AA11, and Exhibit C20. It was his submission that the Claimant’s termination complied with contractual and regulatory framework governing the employment relationship. He argued that in compliance with the principles of fair hearing and the internal disciplinary procedure, the Claimant was issued a formal query which she responded to, and that this satisfies the requirement of fair hearing relying on Yusuf v UBN Ltd supra, Imonikhe v Unity Bank Plc (2013) 12 NWLR (Pt 1262) 624. He argued that on the evidence the Defendant constituted a review panel representing a heightened level of procedural fairness but the Claimant frustrated the process by opting for a virtual hearing and failing to effectively participate on ground of network issues.
[28] Learned counsel submitted that where an employee is given the opportunity to be heard and fails to utilize same, she cannot complain of denial of fair hearing citing Bayero & Anor v Agundi & Ors (2020) LPELR 58512 (SC), Adedeji & Ors v CBN (2022) LPELR-59629 (SC). He further submitted that even where it is not expressly stated in the contract of employment, the law gives an employer the right to terminate the contract for acts of misconduct or willful disobedience citing Benue Brewery Ltd v. Okonta (2024) LPELR-61878(CA). He submitted that the Claimant has failed to discharge the evidential burden placed upon her by law to establish that her termination was wrongful or in breach of her employment contract. He further submitted that the Claimant failed to lead credible evidence in support of her claim for a declaration in relief 1, and her other claims. He urged the Court to resolve all the issues submitted in favour of the Defendant, and consequently dismiss the Claimant’s case for lacking in merit.
[29] The Claimant submitted four issues for determination as follows:
1. Whether the Defendant complied with its own Employee Discipline Policy (POL03011) and applicable workplace regulations in effecting the purported separation of the Claimant from its employ?
2. Whether the disciplinary process activated against the Claimant was tainted by bias, bad faith and a violation of the Claimant's right to fair hearing, such as to render the resultant separation unlawful?
3. Whether the Defendant's defence of estoppel by acceptance of terminal benefits is sustainable in law and on the facts of this case?
4. Having regard to the foregoing, whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought in her Statement of Claim?
[30] Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the centrepiece of the Claimant's case is that the Defendant's separation of her employment was effected without any regard to the mandatory procedures prescribed by its own Employee’s Handbook (Exhibit AA11) and Employee Discipline Policy, POL03011 (Exhibit AA14 and Exhibit C20). He submitted that an employer who has prescribed procedures governing the discipline and separation of its employees is bound by those procedures and cited Skye Bank Plc v. Adegun (2024) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1960) 1 at 36, paras. A-C, Dangote Cememt Plc v Ager (2024) 10 NWLR (Pt 1945) 1 at 36 Para E-A. He referred to paragraph 1.4 page 1, and paragraph 2.5 (Exhibit AA14 and Exhibit C20) and submitted that every step in the disciplinary process must be documented including minutes and a copy given to the employee. He argued that DW did not produce any document showing that any disciplinary step was documented and communicated to the Claimant and that the mandatory processes leading to the separation were not complied with because there was report, recommendation by the panel, or a review meeting with the Claimant citing Savannah Bank (Nig) Plc v Fakokun (2002) 1 NWLR (Pt 749) 544 at 559-560 Para H-D.
[31] Learned Senior Counsel referred to Section 2 of the Employee Discipline Policy POLO3011 and submitted that there has been total non-compliance. It was his contention that the Defendant’s argument at paragraph 5.1.53 - 5.1.56 of its final address that Employee Discipline Policy POL03011 permitted it to apply ‘accelerated discipline’ or ‘immediate separation for a first offense’ cannot survive a reading of Clause 1.3 in its full context as it does not state that documentation is waived when acceleration is chosen. He submitted that the Defendant's National Employee Handbook (Exhibit AA11) grievance procedure at Article 7.1, 7.2, 7.2.1, and 7.3 were not complied with. He further submitted that there were violations of the Open door and No retaliation policy POLO3004 (Exhibit C17). That on the evidence, within six weeks of the Claimant’s escalation of her complaint against Mr Apera, she was queried, a disciplinary review panel constituted, and she received a Separation letter; and that this is a breach of contract citing WAEC v Oshionebo (2006) 12 NWLR (Pt 994) 258 at 271 Para A-C.
[32] Learned Senior Counsel on issue 2 submitted that an employer cannot lawfully dismiss or separate an employee for disciplinary reasons without first affording that employee a fair hearing citing Daramola v. F.U.T., Yola (2026) 4 NWLR (Pt. 2033) 181 @ P. 204, paras. B-D; P. 205, paras. F-H, Olufeagba v Abdul-Raheem (2009) 18 NWLR (Pt 1173) 384, Garba v University of Maiduguri (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt 18) 550 at 553. He argued that that neither the query process nor the panel process met the standard required by law, and that the Defendant's own evidence conclusively confirms this. He submitted that the instruction conveyed on 21st July 2023 that the Claimant's response was ‘unsatisfactory’ was a bare conclusion, not an engagement, and he cited Savannah Bank (Nig) Plc. v. Fakokun (2002) 1 NWLR (Pt. 749) 544 @ Pp.559-560 Paras. H-D. He further submitted that on the evidence, Mr. Iorwakwagh Apera was the person against whom the Claimant had filed a formal complaint of workplace harassment and threats on 19th June 2023 (Exhibit C12); and he was accuser, panelist, and executioner, all in one. He argued that the directive from headquarters preserved flexible work arrangement, and that the Nigerian directive mandated a full return to the office to work which was in direct conflict with the global directive. It was his contention that the disciplinary process activated against the Claimant was void from the outset.
[33] Learned Senior Counsel arguing issue 3 on waiver submitted that the Separation and Release Letter of 27th July 2023 (Exhibit C2) contains an explicit consent clause and provided that: “Final payment will be made upon the return of all FHI 360 assets in your possession.” And were therefore made the explicit prerequisites for any valid release. He argued that the Claimant never signed the letter, and that a unilateral bank credit, deposited by one party without the prior agreement of the other, is not a contract, or a release, or a waiver; and it can produce no legal obligation on the part of the recipient. He cited Dikio v. N.S.I.T.F. Mgt. Board (2025) 14 NWLR (Pt. 2004) 129 @ P. 164, paras. A-D. He argued that letter dated 26th February 2024, written within months of the termination, formally demanding the reversal of the Separation Letter and the payment of all entitlements signed by Claimant’s lead counsel, Adeola Adedipe SAN on behalf of the Claimant, is the clearest possible evidence of protest.
[34] Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the legal requirement that acceptance must be without protest in order to found an estoppel is settled, and he cited NITEL v Ikaro (1994) 1 NWLR (Pt 320) 352 at 363-364 Para G-B, Mr Kurt Severinsen Emerging Markets Telecommunication Services Limited Suit No:NICN/LA/42/2010. It was his submission that the cases cited by the Defendant are distinguishable from this instant case. He referred to Ariori v Elemo supra and submitted that a waiver must be conscious and deliberate election to surrender a known right; and that the mere receipt of a sum of money deposited into one’s account without consent does not constitute free choice to waive legal claims citing Bakare v Ogundipe (2021) 5 NWLR (Pt 1768) 1 at 42. He argued that the Defendant's reliance on the estoppel doctrine is misconceived because the termination itself is void having been effected in violation of an employer's own mandatory disciplinary procedures and in breach of the employee's constitutional right to fair hearing; and that one cannot waive a right against a wrongful termination.
[35] Learned Senior Counsel in arguing issue 4 submitted that the Claimant has discharged the burden of proving her case as stated by the Supreme Court in Oforishe v N.G.C. Ltd supra having identified, clause by clause, the manner in which each governing document was breached. It was his submission that the power to depart from common law restriction of payment of salary in lieu of notice, award damages and compensation, apply equitable principles is found in sections 13, 15, and 19(d) of the National Industrial Court Act 2006. He urged the Court to grant the declaration sought, the ancillary reliefs, and interest on the judgment sum at the rate of 10% per annum from the date of judgment until full satisfaction.
Reply
[36] Replying on point of law, learned defence counsel submitted that the Court cannot rewrite, import into or export out of a contract any term the parties did not agree to, and cited Vital Investment Limited v Chemical and Allied Products (2021) LPELR-58457 (SC). He submitted that the Claimant admitted that a disciplinary panel sat over her matter, and that the law is that facts admitted need no further proof citing Bayam v Agana (2010) 9 NWLR (Pt 1119) 233, Ibadan LGPC v Okunade (2005) 3 NWLR (Pt 911) 45. He submitted that parties are bound by their pleadings and evidence; and a party os not permitted to approbate and reprobate referring to FBN Ltd v Stallionaire Nig Ltd & Anor (2022) LPELR- 57330 (CA). He submitted that the burden of proving retaliation as alleged by the Claimant is on the Claimant and cannot be discharged by conjecture, suspicion or speculation citing NUP v INEC (2021) LPELR-58407(SC). Learned counsel submitted that Ariori v Elemo supra recognizes that waiver may be inferred from conduct clearly demonstrating an election to forego a right. Referring to Section 19(d) if the NICA 2006, he submitted that the provision does not create an automatic right to compensation.
Decision
[37] I have carefully considered the processes filed, the evidence adduced, written submissions and authorities cited by counsel. The law is settled that in the determination of employment rights, it is the employee who complains that his/her employment contract has been breached that has the burden to place before the Court the terms and conditions of his/her employment that provides for his/her rights and obligations, and the manner such terms and conditions were breached; see Oforishe v Nigerian Gas Co Ltd (2017) LPELR-42766 (SC), Buka Modu Aji v Chad Basin Development Authority & Anor (2015) 3-4 SC (Pt III) 1 at 15, Idoniboye-Obe v. NNPC [2003] 2 NWLR (Pt. 805) 589 at 630. It is the law that whoever desires the Court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove those facts exist, section 131 (1) & (2) of the Evidence Act 2011, see Inua v F.B.N. Plc (2016) 1 NWLR (Pt 1495) 89, Uwah v. Akpabio [2014] 7 NWLR (Pt. 1407) at 489.
[38] The Claimant has placed in evidence her offer of employment (Exhibit C1),Re: Separation agreement & release (Exhibit C2), Separation agreement & release (Exhibit C3), Re: separation agreement & release (Exhibit C4), medical certificate (Exhibit C5), Re: Salary in- band (Exhibit C6) Covid 19 requirements (Exhibit C7), email (Exhibit C8), Remote working (Exhibit C9), FHI 360 letter head (Exhibit C10), Email ( Exhibit C11), queries (Exhibit C10), invitation to disciplinary committee (Exhibit C11) claimants reply Complaint (Exhibit C12), list of panel members (Exhibit C13), document titled telecommuting and remote working (Exhibit C14) Request for Panel Members (Exhibit C15), Mrs. Anyanwu’s correspondence (Exhibit C16), FHI 360 Policy (Exhibit C17), FHI 360 Policy (Exhibit C18), FHI 360 Policy (Exhibit C19), FHI 360 Policy (Exhibit C20), Certificate of identification (Exhibit C21). The Defendant has placed before the Court Email (Exhibit D1), Email (Exhibit D2), Email (Exhibit D3), Email (Exhibit D4), Email (Exhibit D5), Email (Exhibit D6), Email (Exhibit D7), FHI 360 Email (Exhibit D8), GTB online transfer (Exhibit D9), Certificate to section 84 (Exhibit D10).
[39] It is not in dispute that the Claimant was employed by the Defendant FHI 360 Nigeria, and began her service on 15th November 2012 as Human Resource Officer. It is also not in dispute that during the Covid-19 pandemic the Defendant put in place Covid-19 related office access restrictions, specifically work from home arrangements, which was a containment measure to protect its employees against the spread of Covid-19. The Global office of the Defendant (in the United States of America) by email of 17th April 2023 (Exhibit C7 & D2) lifted the Covid-19 safety restrictions in all its locations, and kept in place its flexible work arrangements. Upon receipt of this directive, the management of the Defendant took necessary action.
[40] DW who is the Defendant’s Human Resource Manager sent an email on April 19, 2023 to “FHI360_Nigeria_Group” informing all staff as follows:
Following the below mail, this is to inform you that we are ending the work from home arrangements that have been in place immediately.
All employees must report to the office for work. We understand that the work from home arrangement was a convenience for many of us, however it is important to have everyone back in the office to ensure that we are able to fully collaborate and provide the best possible service.
If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to reach me, or your project lead, or the Country Director.
Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.
Regards,
Audu Amushe
[41] The directive of the Defendant in this email is the catalyst to this dispute. Now, I must state that I take judicial notice of the fact that governments, organizations, and businesses around the world, including the Nigerian Judiciary also put in place Covid-19 related office access restrictions, and switched to remote working and telecommuting to keep businesses ongoing as best as they could, and the justice system moving until the pandemic was significantly contained. Thereafter, all over the world physical work, flexible work arrangements, and hybrid work resumed.
[42] The issues that arise for determination are as follows:
1. Whether the Claimant complied with the directives of her employer, FHI 360 Nigeria?
2. Whether the Claimant is estopped in law from filing this complaint upon acceptance of separation pay and terminal benefits?
3. Whether on the pleadings and evidence, the Claimant ought to be entitled to the reliefs she seeks?
[43] The Claimant asserts that she did not receive the email directing all employees to report to the office for work, and as such did not resume work in the office as directed. DW upon the Claimant’s denial of receipt of the mail sent her on 17 May 2023, the same email sent to the Group and informed her it was an organizational directive to all staff. The Claimant replied that same day as follows (Exhibit D3):
Thanks for forwarding.
Although, I have effectively delivered on my job expectations from remotely, the new directive will not work for me in the instant.
Do let me know what options are available.
[44] The Claimant under cross-examination confirmed that Audu Amushe (DW) was her direct supervisor, that she had an official email address, and that she received group emails. How then can the Claimant expect this Court to believe that she did not receive the email sent by her supervisor to all employees through the Group email in his capacity as HR Manager of the Defendant? The Claimant refused to report to the office, and on June 1, 2023 requested for ten (10) days sick leave to take care of her health, and this was granted (Exhibit D4). At the expiration of the ten days sick leave, the Claimant still did not report in the office for duty. By her own testimony, she sent a work from home request to the Defendant on 19th June 2023 (Exhibit C9) and admitted that the Defendant did not permit her to work from home while she was waiting for the response to her request.
[45] On 4 July 2023, DW sent the Claimant a mail checking on her health status and if she is able to work; and she responded that she was “doing well and able to work.”(Exhibit D5). The Defendant considered the Claimant’s request for remote work (Exhibit C9) that she made on grounds of medical emergency, specifically that her younger brother who lives with her underwent brain surgery, and he required her presence for post operative care. The Defendant’s decision refusing her request was communicated to her by email on 7 July 2023 (Exhibit D6). The reason stated is as follows:
While I empathize with your situation, the nature of your role necessitates your physical presence in the office to ensure smooth collaboration and efficient execution of tasks.
Since you have resumed work, please be in the office at the scheduled work time. Failure to be present will result in disciplinary action up to and including separation.
[46] The Claimant asserts that the Defendant failed to consider her request for remote work in line with its remote work policy and on compassionate grounds, and and therefore acted in bad faith. A careful look at Paragraph 1.1 of the Defendant’s Telecommuting and Remote Working Policy (Exhibit C14) states as follows:
Management approval to telecommute, or work remotely, depends on a variety of factors, including, but not limited to, the following: operational and programmatic needs and resources of each organizational unit, project or award requirements or needs; position responsibilities and duties; ability to achieve necessary work objectives and outcomes; individual capacity and resources to work off site; and the availability of appropriate supervision.
[47] The reason for refusal of her request given by the Defendant falls within Paragraph 1.1 of the Policy, specifically the nature of her role, operational needs, position responsibilities and appropriate supervision. Furthermore, the Claimant in her request for remote work stated: “I have put all necessary measures to ensure that my work does not suffer at the same time and that included hiring a home nurse, but his current situation requires having me near him.” It is my considered view that the Defendant properly exercised its discretion when it took the decision to refuse the Claimant’s request for remote work; and I so hold. There is no evidence the Defendant acted in bad faith before the Court. There is no evidence the Defendant acted in bad faith before the Court.
[48] On 10 July 2023, the Claimant was physically at work but left before the closing time to fix her official laptop without physically informing DW her supervisor; rather it is her testimony that she informed him via Team Chat. The Claimant did not report for duty the next day. She admitted in cross-examination that she did not resume physical work. I find from the conduct of the Claimant, and particularly her response to DW her supervisor that: “the new directive will not work for me”, she willfully and deliberately disobeyed her employer’s directives to report to the office for physical work. It was at this stage, the Defendant issued her a query on July 11 (Exhibit C10) for “continued absence after multiple requests for you to work from the FHI 360 Nigeria office” and she responded (Exhibit C16).
[49] The Defendant informed the Claimant (Exhibit C11 & D7) that her response to the query was unsatisfactory; that she still failed to return to the office; that a recommendation for the separation of her employment had been received; and that in line with FHI 360 policies a Review Panel has been established to consider the recommended disciplinary sanctions. The Claimant was also informed that the meeting of the Review Panel would be held on Monday 24 July at the Abuja Office. The Claimant rather than obey the Defendant’s directive and appear physically for such a crucial meeting, sent an email to the Defendant (Exhibit C15) requesting for a virtual meeting instead of the physical meeting, and stating that she would make herself available as long as it is within the work hours. She confirmed that she was invited to the virtual meeting, and in her pleadings averred that the virtual meeting was organized, but it was inconclusive due to poor internet connection. The law is settled that parties are bound by their pleadings, see Luke v RSH & PDA (2023) 3 NWLR (Pt 1871) 221, MTN Nig Comms Ltd v Auta (2020) 8 NWLR (Pt 1871) 221.
[50] The Claimant asserts that she was denied her right to a fair hearing. I find from the evidence adduced that the Claimant was queried, she responded, and she was present at the Review Panel meeting that she requested should be virtual. It is settled law that fair hearing audi alterem partem is satisfied once a party has been given the opportunity to be heard in respect of any matter or cause touching on, or affecting his civil rights and obligations/interest. The rule of fair hearing is not a technical doctrine but a rule of substance, and the question is not whether injustice has been done because of lack of fair hearing, but whether a party entitled to be heard before a decision, had in fact been given the opportunity to be heard, see Skye Bank v Adegun (2024) 15 NWLR (Pt 1960) 1 at 36 Para C-F; Obasan v Abudu (2023) 8 NWLR (Pt 1887) 423, A.P.C. v A.S.I.E.C (2022) 12 NWLR (Pt 1845) 411, Daewoo (Nig) Ltd v Alamina (2022) 14 NWLR Pt 1851 409, Oyeyemi v Owoeye (2017) 12 NWLR (Pt 1580) 364.
[51] The question is was the Claimant given the opportunity to be heard? By the Claimant’s own evidence, she was issued a query, she responded to the query, and she was present at the Review Panel meeting held virtually at her own request. By the Claimant’s own evidence, she was given the opportunity to be heard, during the disciplinary process. The Supreme Court in Imonikhe v Unity Bank Plc [2011] 4 SC (Pt 1) 104 at 135; [2011] 12 NWLR (Pt 1262) 624 at 640 held that where an employer accuses an employee of misconduct by way of a query and the employee answers the query before the employer takes a decision on the employee’s appointment, that satisfies the requirement of fair hearing. I hold that the Defendant did not violate the Claimant’s right to a fair hearing guaranteed in Section 36 (1) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended).
[52] The Defendant on July 27, 2023 issued the Claimant a letter of Separation Agreement and Release (Exhibit C2). The letter states that the reason for her separation from the Defendant’s employment is: “for your repeated failure to obey lawful instructions”. Her terminal benefits including her separation pay of one month basic salary were computed making a total N2,333,658.72. The Claimant was asked to consent as follows:
Please indicate your consent by signing in the space provided, by which you also acknowledge and agree that this summary of final entitlement payments is just and true, and as such constitutes full and final payment; and that upon receipt of this final payment, you hereby release FHI 360/Nigeria and all its officials and affiliates of all liabilities, obligations, payments, and claims related to your employment with FHI 360/Nigeria. Final payment will be made upon the return of all FHI 360 assets in your possession.
[53] The Claimant did not sign the Separation Agreement and Release. About five weeks later, specifically 04 September 2023, the Defendant paid the Claimant’s terminal benefits into her Guaranty Trust Bank account (Exhibit D9). The Claimant did not protest the payment, or return the separation pay and terminal benefits to the Defendant when she received the sum. Rather, she held on to it. The Defendant on 28th February 2023 (almost six months later) received a letter from the Claimant’s counsel (Exhibit C3), which in paragraph 2.3.6 of the Claimant’s final address is referred to as the “Pre-Action Letter” and “the clearest possible evidence of protest”. I do not find this to be a letter protesting the Defendant’s payment of separation pay and terminal benefits into the Claimant’s bank account. Rather, it is a letter of demand wherein the Claimant’s counsel is demanding the following: that the separation letter be set aside or reversed, an apology from the Defendant, the Claimant be allowed to put in a resignation notice, payment of all entitlements till the date of resignation, and compensation in the sum of Five Hundred Million Naira.
[54] Learned Senior Counsel has argued that the Claimant having not signed the Separation Agreement and Release, the payment of her terminal benefits was unilateral and produces no legal obligation on the Claimant recipient. The law is settled that where the employee has accepted his/her terminal benefits without any protest after the employment was brought to an end, he/she cannot be heard to complain later that his/her contract of employment was not properly determined. The acceptance of payment of terminal benefits by the employee renders the determination mutual. Estoppel by conduct operates to disqualify the employee; and in this instance, the Claimant who accepted her separation pay and terminal benefits without protest is precluded from alleging improper determination of her employment having been paid one month basic salary in lieu of notice and her terminal benefits as computed in the separation letter, see Shuaibu &Ors v NBC Plc (Caca-Cola) (2020) LPELR-52110 CA at 58; Imperial Medical Centre v Ahamefule (2017) LPELR-42886 CA; Ekeagwu v Nigerian Army & Anor (2006) LPELR-7641 at 16-17 Para F-F, Julius Berger v Nwegwu (2005) 12 NWLR (Pt 995) 518.
[55] The case of Mr Kurt Severinsen v Emerging Markets Telecommunication Services Limited supra referred to by the Claimant in paragraph 2.3.7 of the final address is distinguishable, in that Mr Kurt Severinsen signed the release and discharge certificate under protest, stating on the discharge certificate/document that he had reservations as to the contents of the said certificate, and that he did not waive his right to receive a bonus payment. This is not the case here. The Claimant did not protest upon receiving the payment, but held on to it.
[56] It is the law that a person who is sui juris, can waive a right conferred upon him by a statute or contract where the right is for his sole benefit, see Ariori v Elemo (1983) LPELR-552 (SC). The Claimant waived her right when she accepted the separation pay and terminal benefits without protest as her full and final payment. By accepting her separation pay and terminal benefits without protest, she has consented, and has released the Defendant, and all its officials and affiliates of all liabilities, obligations, payments and claims related to her employment as stated in the Separation Agreement and Release. The Claimant is therefore barred from instituting this action; and I so hold.
[57] Having waived her right, the Claimant is estopped from alleging that the Defendant failed to comply with its employee discipline policy (POL03011), guidelines, directives, and applicable workplace regulations in her separation and release; and also estopped from her unproven allegations against Mr Iorwakwagh Apera the Defendant’s Country Manager, and Mr Audu Amushe the HR Manager. A right that has been waived is lost, see Bakare v Ogundipe (2021) 5 NWLR (Pt 1768) 1 at 42.
[58] Now, the Defendant having stated the reason for the separation and release of the Claimant as being ‘repeated failure to obey lawful instructions’, the law imposes on the Defendant a duty to justify the reason to the satisfaction of the Court, see Skye Bank v Adegun (2024) 15 NWLR (Pt 1960) 1 at 39-40 Para F-C; I.H.A.B.U.H.M.B v Anyip (2013) 12 NWLR (Pt 1260) 1; S.P.D.C v Olanrewaju (2008) 18 NWLR (Pt 118) 1 SC, Afribank (Nig) Plc v Osisanya (2000) 1 NWLR (Pt 642) 592, Olatunbosin v NISER Council [1988] 3 NWLR (Pt 80) 25. The wrong doing of the employee must be connected with the conduct and performance of the employee’s work. This is in accordance with international labour standards, and international best practices in labour, employment and industrial relations matters which this Court has a duty to apply, see section 254C (1)(f) & (h) 1999 Constitution (as amended); Sahara Energy Resources Ltd v Oyebola (2020) LPELR-51806 (CA), Skye Bank v Adegun supra.
[59] The Supreme Court in Sule v Nigerian Cotton Board (1985) 6 SC (Reprint) 57 at 88-89 stated as follows, per Obaseki JSC (of blessed memory):
When a servant grows too big to obey his master, the honourable cause open to him is to resign in order to avoid unpleasant consequences should an occasion which calls for obedience be served with disobedience. Both the common law and statute law brook no disobedience of lawful order from any servant, high or low, big or small. Such conduct normally and usually attract the penalty of summary dismissal. Disobedience ranks as one of the worst form of misconduct in any establishment……….
Notwithstanding that the appellant’s employment had statutory flavour, the peculiar facts of the case completely deny to him the protection of those statutory provisions. His misconduct lies in the fact that by his assumed outlawry he could act with impunity.
[60] The Claimant’s repeated disobedience to lawful instructions from constituted authority shows that she had grown too big to obey the Defendant her master, and the honourable cause open to her was to have resigned when she could no longer work physically. Also see Yusuf v UBN Ltd [1996] 6 NWLR (Pt. 457) 632 SC; Mr Ibrahim Alabi Is-Haq v Computer Professional (Registration Council of Nigeria) unreported Suit No: NICN/ABJ/348/2016 judgment delivered August 9, 2022.
[61] From the totality of the evidence adduced, I am satisfied that the Defendant has justified the reason that necessitated the separation and release of the Claimant from its employment. The separation and release of the Claimant from the Defendant’s employment was lawful; and I so hold.
[61] For all the reasons given above, the Claimant has failed to prove her case. Consequently, she is not entitled to the declaration she is seeking in relief 1. It fails and is hereby refused. The declaration having failed, the ancillary orders sought in reliefs 2, 3, 4, and 5 must also fail having no foundation, see Olayemi v. FHA (2023) 3 NWLR (Pt. 1872) 445 at 500, Para E (SC); Ogoke v. Nduka (2020) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1715) 509 at 529, Paras A-G (CA); Sunko (Nig) Ltd v. Skye Bank Plc (2017) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1579) 237 at 270, Paras F-H (CA); Nwaogu v Atuma (2013) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1364) 117 at 156, Para D (SC).
[62] The Claimant’s case is dismissed. Costs awarded the Defendant in the sum of N300,000.00.
Judgment is entered accordingly.
____________________________
Hon Justice O. A. Obaseki-Osaghae