IN THE NATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COURT OF
NIGERIA
IN THE PORT HARCOURT JUDICIAL DIVISION
HOLDEN AT PORT HARCOURT
BEFORE
HIS LORDSHIP HON. JUSTICE M. A. HAMZA
DATE: 18TH NOVEMBER, 2026
SUIT NO: NICN/PHC/134/2022
BETWEEN:
MR. GODDEY WARREN ........................................
CLAIMANT
AND
INTERNATIONAL CONTAINER TERMINAL
SERVICES NIGERIA LTD…………..... DEFENDANT
REPRESENTATION
G.
W. WAAGBAA Esq. for the Claimant
EBENEZER
C. UNACHUKWU Esq. for the Defendant
JUDGMENT
1.
On the 23rd day of September 2022 the Claimant filed this complaint against the
Defendant seeking for the following reliefs:
1. A
Declaration that there exists a valid contract of employment between the
Claimant and the Defendant and that the said contract was unjustly and
wrongfully terminated by the Defendant on 25th day of July, 2022, without any
terminal benefits.
2. A
Declaration that the demand for the refund of Three Million, Five Hundred
Thousand Naira (?3,500,000.00), trainer
retainership fees from the Claimant by the Defendant is unlawful and run
contrary to the provision of the terms and condition of employment.
3.
An Order directing/compelling the Defendant to assist the Claimant with
authorization to recover his pension from Sigma Pension.
4.
An Order directing the Defendant to pay to the Claimant the sum of One Hundred
and Three Million, Three Hundred and Twenty Thousand Naira (?103,320,000.00)
representing Three Million, Three Hundred and Twenty thousand Naira (?3,320,000.00)
as special damages and One Hundred and Fifty Million Naira (?150,000,000.00)
as general damages for unjust and wrongful termination of the Claimant’s employment, loss of
earning, stigmatization, discrimination as well as untold emotional physical and
psychological pain and trauma suffered by the Claimant for the wrongful
termination of employment.
5.
Interest on the judgment sum at the rate of 10% per annum till judgment is
fully complied with by the Defendant.
2.
Other initiating processes were filed along with the Complaint in lines with
the Rules of this Court. In response, the Defendant entered appearance through
its Counsel and filed its Statement of Defence together with a Counterclaim
wherein the Defendant counterclaimed as follows:
a. A
Declaration that the Claimant’s repeated unauthorized absence/gross misconduct
was a constructive repudiation of his Contract of Employment with the Defendant
and therefore a breach of the Employment Contract between them.
b.
An Order directing the Claimant to refund the sum of Three Million, Five
Hundred Thousand Naira (?3,500,000.00) only to the
Defendant being the amount of money paid to the Claimant’s previous employer as
trainer retainership fee.
c.
The sum of One Hundred and Forty-Six Thousand, Five Hundred and Twenty Thousand
US Dollars ($146.520) or its Naira equivalent at the prevailing exchange rate
only being special damages of the loss incurred due to the Claimant’s
unauthorized absences from work without prior notices or justification.
d.
Five Million Naira (?5,000,000.00) only as
general damages for the breach of contract and loss suffered due to the breach
and the Claimant’s
repeated unauthorized absence/gross misconduct.
e.
Ten Million Naira (?10,000,000.00) only as cost
of this suit.
f.
Pre-judgment interest of 10% per annum on the sums of Three Million, Five
Hundred Thousand Naira (?3,500,000.00) and One
Hundred and Forty-Six Thousand, Five Hundred and Twenty Thousand US Dollars
($146.520) (or its Naira equivalent at the prevailing exchange rate) from the
1st of August, 2022 till the date judgment is delivered in this suit.
g.
Post-judgment interest of 10% per annum from the date judgment is delivered in
this suit till it is fully liquidated.
The case of the Claimant as Pleaded
3.
The Claimant’s case, as pleaded is that he is a trained and certified MHC crane
operator employed at the Defendant’s Onne Multipurpose Terminal by a letter of
offer dated 23 April 2021, with confirmation effective from 27 July 2021. He
operated the Defendant’s LHM 550 crane and worked day and night shifts. He
states that he became ill on 22 July 2022, received medical treatment and was
discharged on 23 July 2022. He says he informed persons connected with his
shift, including Mr. Josiah Lel gengor and Mr. Adotee Messavussu, expecting
that the information would be relayed to the Shift Manager. The Defendant
issued a query on 25 July 2022 requiring a response within one hour. He
responded that his absence on 22 and 23 July was due to illness, but his
employment was terminated that same day without notice and without proper
consideration of his explanation. The Claimant further alleges that his July
salary and terminal benefits were withheld; that he does not owe the Defendant ?3,500,000.00
because the contractual repayment condition was not triggered; that the
Defendant has impeded the release of his pension benefits with Sigma Pension;
and that a security report concerning the alleged debt adversely affected his
subsequent application for work at Lekki Freeport Terminal. He attributes
financial hardship, embarrassment and emotional distress to the Defendant’s
conduct.
The Case of the Defendant as Pleaded
4.
The Defendant admits the employment relationship but says it was governed by
the letter of offer, terms and conditions, and the Employee Handbook
incorporated by clause 12 of the terms and conditions. It alleges repeated
absence without notice, leave or authorisation on 6 March, 10 May, 30 May, 30
June, 9 July, 19 July, 22 July and 23 July 2022, and says these absences
disrupted operations and breached clauses 2.13 and 2.15.11 of the Handbook.
The
Defendant says the Claimant was queried on previous occasions; that he did not
comply with the required medical reporting procedure; and that during an
investigation he initially identified Patfare Hospital, Rukpokwu, but the
hospital allegedly denied that he had attended there. It disputes the
reliability and timing of Exhibit C3, the medical report. The Defendant relies
on clause 2.25.1 and related provisions of the Handbook as authorising summary
termination for gross misconduct or material breach. The Defendant also averred
that it paid ?3,500,000.00 to the Claimant’s former employer to secure
his release and that clause 11.3 of the terms and conditions made the amount
refundable if the Claimant did not remain employed for two years. It
characterizes the repeated absences as constructive repudiation and claims
operational losses, general damages, professional fees and interest.
5.
At trial, the Claimant gave evidence as CW1, and Ebika Michael testified as DW1
on behalf of the Defendant. The Court subsequently directed Counsel to the
parties to file their respective final written addresses in line with the Rules
of this Court and they complied with the said direction.
Defendant Final Written Address
6.
In the Defendant’s Final Written Address, Counsel raised issues for
determinations:
1.
Whether in the circumstance of this suit, the contract of employment between
the Claimant and the Defendant was wrongly and unjustly terminated.
2.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
3.
Whether the Defendant is entitled to its counterclaim.
7.
Arguing issue one, on whether in the circumstance of this suit, the contract of
employment between the Claimant and the Defendant was wrongly and unjustly
terminated. Counsel submitted that the totality of the evidence established
that the Claimant’s employment was lawfully terminated in accordance with the
terms and conditions governing the employment relationship, following his
repeated unauthorised absences from work, which constituted gross misconduct
under the Employee Handbook incorporated into the contract of employment.
Counsel relied on the principle that an employer who has the right to hire has
the corresponding right to terminate employment in accordance with the
governing contract. In support, Counsel CITED ANGEL SPINNING DYEING LTD. V.
AJAH (2000) 13 NWLR (PT. 685) 532 AND OBE V. NIGERSOL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LTD.
(1972) 2 U.I.L.R (PT. II) 121.
8.
Counsel argued that the Claimant’s employment was governed by the Letter of
Offer of Employment dated 23 April 2021 and the Employee Handbook, which was
incorporated into the contract by Clause 12 of the Terms and Conditions of
Employment. Relying on U.B.N. PLC V. SOARES (2012) 11 NWLR (PT. 1312) 550 AT
554, Counsel submitted that parties are bound by the terms of their contract
and that clear contractual provisions must be given effect. Counsel maintained
that Paragraph 7 of the Terms and Conditions permitted termination by one
month’s salary in lieu of notice but also reserved the Defendant’s right to
terminate summarily, without notice or payment in lieu, in circumstances
recognised by the Employee Handbook.
9.
Counsel further submitted that Clauses 2.25.1 and 3.3.2.4 of the Employee
Handbook permitted termination for material breach of contract or gross
misconduct, while Clause 2.13 imposed attendance and punctuality obligations,
including the requirement that an employee notify the appropriate supervisor or
Head of Department as soon as possible when late or absent.
According
to Counsel, the Claimant repeatedly breached those requirements despite verbal
warnings and written queries. Counsel relied on the Employee Attendance
Register, Exhibit D10, which allegedly established the Claimant’s absences on
several dates between March and July 2022. Counsel argued that the Claimant’s
oral denial could not displace the documentary evidence and cited HUEBNER V.
AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING (2008) 2 NWLR (PT. 1071) 378 AND FAYEMI V.
ONI (2009) 7 NWLR (PT. 1140) 223.
10.
Counsel also contended that the Claimant had been given opportunities to
explain his conduct through the queries and responses contained in Exhibits
C11, C12, D3 and D4. Counsel referred to Exhibit D8, comprising email
correspondence, as evidence of recurring absenteeism and the operational and
financial difficulties allegedly caused by the Claimant’s absence, including
difficulties in arranging replacement personnel.
With
respect to the Claimant’s medical explanation, Counsel argued that Exhibit C3
was produced subsequently and was inconsistent with the Claimant’s earlier
account of where he received treatment. Counsel relied on the evidence that the
Claimant allegedly mentioned Patfare Hospital, Rukpokwu, during an
investigation, but that the hospital denied that he had attended or been
admitted there. Counsel further submitted that the Claimant had access to
medical facilities under the Defendant’s HMO arrangement but obtained the
medical report from a health centre outside that network. Counsel therefore
urged the Court to treat Exhibit C3 with caution or discountenance it as an
afterthought.
11.
Counsel further relied on Exhibit D14, a WhatsApp communication between the
Claimant and his supervisor, as evidence that the Claimant knew his repeated
absenteeism could result in termination. Counsel maintained that the absences
were repeated, contrary to the Employee Handbook, continued despite warnings,
disrupted operations and amounted to gross misconduct.
The
authorities cited in support were OYEDELE V. I.U.T.H (1990) 6 NWLR (PT. 155)
194; C.B.N. V. ARIBO (2018) 4 NWLR (PT. 1608) 130; AND ADEWUNMI V. NIGERIAN
EAGLE FLOUR MILLS (2014) 14 NWLR (PT. 1428) 443.
Counsel
concluded on this issue that the Claimant had failed to establish the specific
contractual provision breached by the Defendant. Rather, the Letter of Offer
and the incorporated Employee Handbook authorised summary termination in cases
of gross misconduct and the Claimant’s repeated unauthorised absences justified
the Defendant’s decision.
12.
Arguing issue two on whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought,
Counsel submitted that the Claimant had failed to establish any legal or
evidential basis for the reliefs claimed. Having regard to the Defendant’s
contention that the termination was lawful, Counsel argued that the
consequential claims founded on wrongful termination must fail. Counsel further
submitted that the Claimant had not demonstrated any breach of the contract
and, under cross-examination, had acknowledged access to his pension benefits
with Sigma Pension. The Defendant therefore contended that the Claimant had not
established entitlement to the additional monetary reliefs sought.
13.
On the claim for the ?3,500,000 trainer
retainership fee, Counsel argued that the demand for repayment was based on the
contractual requirement that the Claimant remain in the Defendant’s employment
for a minimum period of two years. According to Counsel, the fee became
refundable upon the Claimant’s failure to fulfil that commitment, and the
failure resulted from his own repeated misconduct rather than any wrongful act
by the Defendant.
14.
Arguing issue three on whether the Defendant is entitled to its counterclaim,
Counsel submitted that the Claimant’s repeated unauthorised absences, despite
several verbal and written warnings, amounted to a repudiatory breach of the
employment contract. Counsel relied on Exhibit D14, arguing that the Claimant’s
message to his supervisor demonstrated a lack of remorse and an apparent
awareness that his conduct could result in termination.
Counsel
maintained that the contractual obligation to remain in employment for two
years made the ?3,500,000 trainer
retainership fee recoverable because the Claimant failed to fulfil that
commitment through his own misconduct.
15.
Counsel also argued that the Claimant’s absences caused the Defendant
operational and financial losses, allegedly amounting to One Hundred and
Forty-Six Thousand, Five Hundred and Twenty Thousand US Dollars ($146.520),
because the Defendant could not make timely arrangements for replacement
personnel. Counsel contended that the loss was established through documentary
evidence, including queries and email correspondence, and that the Claimant had
not effectively controverted the evidence. The Defendant therefore urged the
Court to award the claimed special damages, ?5,000,000
general damages, ?10,000,000 professional
fees, and the claimed pre-judgment and post-judgment interest.
Counsel
consequently urged the Court to dismiss the Claimant’s claims and grant the
reliefs sought in the Defendant’s counterclaim.
Claimant’s Final Written Address
16.
In the Claimant’s Final Written Address at page 278 of the record, learned
Counsel formulated three issues for determination:
1.
Whether the summary determination of the Claimant’s employment by the
Defendant, on the allegation of absence from duty contrary to the provisions of
the contract of employment, amounted to a breach of contract.
2.
Whether the Defendant proved gross misconduct on the ground of the alleged
absence from duty sufficient to warrant summary termination without notice or
salary in lieu, having regard to the medical evidence tendered by the Claimant
and the totality of the evidence before the Court.
3.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
17.
Arguing issue one on whether the summary termination amounted to a breach of
contract, Counsel submitted that the relationship between an employer and
employee is contractual and that the rights and obligations of the parties are
governed by the contract of employment and any staff handbook incorporated into
it. Counsel relied on KPEREGBE V. NIGERIAN PORTS AUTHORITY (1991) 3 NWLR (PT.
176) 526.
Counsel
argued that Clauses 3.3.2.2 and 3.3.2.4 of the Employee Handbook did not
classify absence from duty as gross misconduct warranting summary dismissal.
Rather, according to Counsel, the prescribed sanction for absence was deduction
of salary for the period of absence. Counsel contended that the Defendant could
not lawfully impose summary dismissal for conduct for which the contract
prescribed a different sanction. Counsel relied on UNION BANK OF NIGERIA LTD VS
IFATUROTI (2002) 13 NWLR (Pt. 785) 73.
18.
Counsel further submitted that the Claimant complied with the relevant
provisions of the Employee Handbook concerning absence occasioned by illness.
Counsel argued that, pursuant to Clause 2.15.11, the Claimant produced medical
evidence in support of his condition and, in compliance with Clause 2.13,
notified the relevant officers. Specifically, the Claimant allegedly contacted
Mr Josiah Lel gengor for onward communication to the Shift Manager, Mr Jeremiah
Ogerbipi, and also contacted Mr Adotee Messavussu.
Counsel
argued that the Defendant did not effectively rebut this evidence or call the
officers concerned to contradict the Claimant’s account. Counsel cited OMOREGBE
V. LAWANI (1980) 3–4 SC 108 AND NWABUOKU V. OTTIH (1961) 1 ALL NLR 487 in
support of the submission that unchallenged and uncontroverted evidence may be
accepted and acted upon by the Court.
19.
Counsel contended that the medical evidence showed that the Claimant was
admitted for treatment on 19 July 2022 and discharged on 23 July 2022.
According to Counsel, 19, 20 and 21 July were the Claimant’s off-duty days,
leaving only 22 and 23 July as the days of actual absence occasioned by
illness. Counsel argued that the Defendant acted with undue haste by issuing
the termination letter on 25 July 2022 without adequately investigating the
medical report, the circumstances of the absence or the Claimant’s compliance
with the Employee Handbook. Counsel relied on MR. C.A. FASONWA V. NIGERIAN
AIRWAYS LTD. (2001) 4 NWLR (PT. 702) 259; Coal Corporation v. SPDC Plc (2005) 15
NWLR (Pt. 946) 387; and Nigerian Ports Authority v. Olujobi (2009) 5 NWLR (Pt.
1133) 535.
20.
Arguing issue two on whether the Defendant proved gross misconduct warranting
summary termination, Counsel submitted that the Defendant failed to prove that
the alleged absence from duty constituted gross misconduct sufficient to
justify summary termination without notice or salary in lieu. Counsel argued
that gross misconduct must be sufficiently serious to justify the drastic
consequence of summary dismissal and that the burden of establishing the
alleged misconduct rested on the party asserting it. Counsel cited AJAYI V.
TEXACO NIG. LTD. (1987) 3 NWLR (PT. 62) 577 AND YUSUF V. UNION BANK OF NIGERIA
(1996) 6 NWLR (PT. 457) 632.
21.
Counsel maintained that the Claimant’s absence was involuntary and
health-related, supported by medical documentation and communication with
relevant officers. Counsel argued that the evidence did not establish that the
Claimant’s absence was deliberate or that he intended to abandon his employment
or disregard his duties. In support, Counsel cited SHELL PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT
CO. V. OLANREWAJU (2008) 18 NWLR (PT. 1118) 1; BAMGBOYE V. UNILORIN (1999) 10
NWLR (PT. 622) 290; AND ARINZE V. FIRST BANK OF NIGERIA LTD. (2000) 1 NWLR (PT.
639) 78.
22.
Counsel further submitted that the Claimant was not given a meaningful
opportunity to explain the medical circumstances surrounding his absence.
Counsel argued that the Defendant introduced matters relating to a private
transaction between the Claimant and Obele Chute instead of properly
investigating the medical evidence and the Claimant’s explanation.
Counsel
also pointed out that Exhibit C6, the termination letter dated 25 July 2022,
was issued on the same date as the disciplinary panel, which, according to
Counsel, demonstrated undue haste and an inadequate investigation. Counsel
relied on INSTITUTE OF HEALTH, ABU HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT BOARD V. ANIP (2011) 12
NWLR (PT. 1260) 1 AND AFOLAYAN V. UNIVERSITY OF ILORIN (2014) 15 NWLR (PT.
1430) 304.
23.
Arguing issue three on whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought,
Counsel submitted that the Defendant breached the contract of employment by
terminating the Claimant’s employment without complying with the applicable
contractual requirements. Counsel argued that where the alleged misconduct did
not justify summary dismissal, the Defendant remained bound to give the
appropriate notice or pay salary in lieu of notice.
In
support, Counsel relied on Section 8 of the Trade Disputes Act, Cap. T8, Laws
of the Federation of Nigeria 2004; GORAM V. NCC (2006) 4 NWLR (PT. 966) 564;
CHUKWUMAH V. SHELL PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT COMPANY (1993) 4 NWLR (PT. 289) 512;
and Section 254C of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999
(as amended).
24.
Counsel contended that, having established that the Defendant wrongfully
terminated his employment, the Claimant was entitled to the declaratory and
monetary reliefs sought in the complaint, including the reliefs arising from
the alleged breach of contract.
The
Claimant accordingly urged the Court to resolve the issues in his favour and
grant the reliefs claimed.
There
was no reply on point of law.
COURT’S DECISIONS
Issues for Determination
25.
Having considered the pleadings, the evidence as described in the record
supplied, the exhibits and the submissions of Counsel, the Court hereby
distilled the following the issues for determination as they thrust of action
to wit:
1.
Is the summary termination of the claimant’s employment by the Defendant
wrongful in the circumstance of this case on 25 July 2022 for repeated
unauthorized absence/gross misconduct and has the Claimant proved entitlement
to each of the reliefs sought?
2.
Whether the Defendant proved each head of its counterclaim.
Before
resolving the above issue, it is necessary to resolve the issue as to the
nature the claimant’s employment relationship with the Defendant and the issue
as to what regulate the employment relationship between the parties.
By
paragraph 3 and 4 of the statement of fact at page 9 of the record, the
claimant became an employee of the Defendant via letter of offer of employment
dated 23/4/2021 exhibit C1 with his employment confirmed on the 31/3/2022
Exhibit C2. Paragraph 12.1 of letter of offer of employment dated 23/4/2021
exhibit C1 is to the effect that the Claimants employment is subject to the
terms and conditions of employment incorporated in the Employee Handbook which
is before the court as Exhibit D2.
Consequently,
I am of the view that the determination of respective right, duties and
liabilities of the parties are to be determined based on contract of employment
before the court as letter of offer of employment dated 23/4/2021 Exhibit C1,
Confirmation of Employment letter dated 31/3/2022 Exhibit C2 and Employee
Handbook Exhibit D2.
Is the summary termination of the
claimant’s employment by the Defendant wrongful in the circumstance of this
case on 25 July 2022 for repeated unauthorized absence/gross misconduct and has
the Claimant proved entitlement to each of the reliefs sought?
26.
In a claim for wrongful termination, the employee must plead and prove the
terms of the contract and identify the manner in which the employer breached
them. The Court is to interpret the agreed terms, not make a new contract for
either party. See OVIVIE VS DELTA STEEL CO. LTD. (2023) 14 NWLR (Pt. 1904) 203
at 228–229. The Defendant, having relied on misconduct as the reason for
dispensing with notice, must in turn establish the facts relied upon to bring
the case within the contractual power of summary termination.
Whether summary termination was
contractually justified
27.
The Defendant relies on Exhibit D10, described as the attendance register, to
show absences on several dates between March and July 2022. The Claimant is
said to have acknowledged in cross-examination that employees used the
register. The register is relevant evidence of recorded attendance. However,
absence from a register does not, without considering the applicable roster,
leave status, notification evidence and explanation for each date, necessarily
establish that every recorded absence was unauthorised or wilful.
28.
The evidence before the court is that the Claimant was absent on 22 and 23 July
2022 and relied on Exhibit C3, a medical report said to record
treatment/admission from 19 to 23 July 2022. The Claimant’s case is that 19, 20
and 21 July were his off-duty days and that he notified Mr Josiah Lel gengor
and Mr. Adotee Messavussu. The Defendant disputes the medical explanation and
says that, during its investigation, Patfare Hospital denied that the Claimant
had attended there.
The
Court distinguish between direct evidence and an account of what an absent
third party allegedly said. If DW1 personally participated in the telephone
call, his evidence may establish that a call occurred; whether the hospital’s
alleged statement proves the truth of the matter asserted depends on the
applicable rules of evidence and the circumstances in which the statement was
made. No hospital representative testified or that a certified hospital record
was tendered. The Court therefore cannot treat the alleged denial by the
hospital as conclusive proof that Exhibit C3 was false. Equally, the mere
production of a medical report does not by itself prove that the Claimant
complied with every contractual requirement for prompt notification or
certification.
29.
The Claimant’s evidence that he contacted the two named officers is said not to
have been directly contradicted by calling those officers. The principle in OMOREGBE
V. LAWANI (1980) 3–4 SC 108 AND NWABUOKU V. OTTIH (1961) 1 ALL NLR 487 is that
credible evidence which is material and unchallenged may be accepted; it is not
an inflexible rule that every unchallenged assertion must be accepted
regardless of its quality or the rest of the evidence. The Court must assess
all the evidence together.
The
Defendant also relies on earlier absences, warnings and queries, including
Exhibits C11, C12, D3 and D4, and the correspondence in Exhibit D8. Those
documents may support the contention that attendance was a recurring issue and
that the Claimant had been alerted to the applicable rules. Nevertheless, the
Court not satisfied that these documents establish the alleged dates, the
requirement breached and the contractual basis for the sanction imposed.
30.
On fair opportunity to respond, the Exhibit C4 and C5 indicates that the
Claimant received the query dated 25 July 2022 and submitted a response before
the termination letter was issued that day. A private employment dispute is not
automatically governed by the full procedure of a criminal trial. The question
is whether the contract and applicable disciplinary provisions were followed
and whether the Claimant had a real opportunity to answer the allegations
relied upon. The fact that an employer rejects an employee’s explanation does
not alone establish unfairness; equally, issuing a query is not a complete
answer if the employer had already decided the matter or failed to consider the
response.
31.
The Court has also considered the international labour standards point. Nigeria
has not ratified the ILO Termination of Employment Convention, 1982 (No. 158),
so it cannot be treated as a ratified convention directly applicable under
section 254C(2) of the Constitution. Its principles may, however, be considered
as a source of international best practice under section 254C(1)(f) and (h) of
the Constitution and section 7(6) of the National Industrial Court Act 2006,
where relevant to the dispute. Articles 4 and 7 of Convention No. 158
respectively address valid reasons for termination and an opportunity to defend
against allegations of misconduct. The Court uses those principles only as a
benchmark of best practice, not as a domesticated or ratified treaty
obligation. The ILO’s official NORMLEX ratification record lists Nigeria’s
ratifications and does not include Convention No. 158. See ILO, ‘Ratifications
for Nigeria’ and ILO, ‘C158, Termination of Employment Convention, 1982 (No.
158)’.
32.
Applying the contractual provisions and the evidence described, the Court finds
that the attendance register and previous disciplinary correspondence support
the Defendant’s case that attendance had been a recurring concern.
Clause
2.13 of the Staff Employee Handbook of Exhibit D2 on Attendance &
Punctuality stated thus:
“Your
attendance and punctuality will be seen as crucial indicators of your
commitment to the Company.
The
biometrics clocking-in accessibility will be used to monitor time-in and
time-out. No staff may sign in for another; this will be regarded as fraud and
will be deemed as Gross
Misconduct,
bringing about summary dismissal. It is an employee’s responsibility to justify
absence from work for the period which he/she is supposed to be at work.
If
you are going to be late for work or absent for a day or more for any reason,
you must contact your Supervisor/Head of Department as soon as possible.
Failure to do so will mean loss of pay for the day(s) involved and may, at the
discretion of the Company, be a ground for dismissal or termination of your
employment contract.”
33.
The case of the claimant is not that he contacted his Supervisor/Head of
Department as provided for in Clause 2.13 of the Staff Employee Handbook of
Exhibit D2. But he contacted one Mr. Josiah Lel gengor and Mr Adotee
Messavussu. There is no evidence before the Court that these persons are the
Claimant’s Supervisor/Head of Department as provided for in Clause 2.13 of the
Staff Employee Handbook of Exhibit D2. The Defendant’s case in paragraph 16 of
the Statement of Defence and Counter claim is that the claimant never informed
his supervisor or shift manager.
However
paragraph 7.3 of Exhibit C1 the Letter of Employment is to the effect that the
Company reserved the right to terminate your appointment summarily (i.e without
notice or payment in lieu of notice) in circumstance detailed in the Employee
Handbook.
Consequently,
I find that the Defendant has proved a pattern of unauthorised absence, prior
the termination and an opportunity to answer the final query. I also find that
the Defendant has justify the reason for the termination of the claimant’s
employment. I hold that the summary-termination is not wrongful.
The ?3,500,000.00
trainer retainership fee
34.
The issue of the trainer retainership fee is separate from the lawfulness of
the termination. The Defendant relies on clause 11.3 as imposing a two-year
commitment and requiring repayment of ?3,500,000.00
if the commitment is not completed. The Claimant says the repayment condition
was not triggered because he did not resign or voluntarily leave for another
employment; the Defendant terminated his employment.
Clause
11.3 of Exhibit C1 provides thus:
“A
one-off trainer retainership fee of ?3,500,000
paid on your behalf remains a bond to continue to render your services for a 2
year regime, this however will be fully recovered from you should you choose to
sever from our employ anytime before the expiration of the agreed 2 years term
which is a breach of this clause.”
The
operative phrase from the above clause is: ‘should you choose to sever from our
employ any time before the expiration of the agreed 2 years term which is a
breach of this clause.’
35.
The Claimant did not choose to leave the Defendant; rather, it was the
Defendant that chose to sever the employment relationship with the Claimant. A
contractual repayment obligation cannot be enlarged by implication beyond the
circumstances for which the parties provided. The Defendant’s characterization
of the Claimant’s conduct as “constructive repudiation” does not, without clear
contractual wording, convert a termination initiated by the employer into a
resignation by the employee.
The
Claimant’s second relief therefore succeeds to this limited extent: the
Defendant has not proved, on the contractual provision an enforceable right to
recover the ?3,500,000.00 in the circumstances of this
case. This finding does not invalidate any clearly worded contractual
obligation that might apply to a different set of facts; it determines only the
demand pleaded and proved here.
Pension relief
36.
The Claimant seeks an order requiring the Defendant to assist with
authorisation to recover his pension from Sigma Pension. There is no evidence
establishing that the Defendant unlawfully withheld pension contributions or
that a particular act of authorisation remains outstanding and within the
Defendant’s control. Without proof of the alleged obstruction and the precise
act required, a mandatory order cannot be made. This relief fails on the
evidence described.
Special and general damages; interest
37.
The Claimant claims ?3,320,000.00 as special
damages and ?150,000,000.00 as general damages. Special
damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved. In UNION BANK OF
NIGERIA PLC V. ALHAJI ADAMS AJABULE & ANOR. (2011) 18 NWLR (PT. 1278) 152,
the Supreme Court reaffirmed that a court cannot award special damages on
conjecture or a fluid estimate; the amount must be established by the facts and
credible evidence.
The
claim for special damages therefore fails. The claim for general damages is
predicated on wrongful termination, loss of earnings, stigmatisation,
discrimination and emotional or psychological injury. It is the finding of this
Court that that termination in this case was contractually justified, the foundation
for damages for wrongful termination is not established. No independent
actionable wrong or evidence sufficient to sustain the pleaded general damages.
The claim for ?150,000,000.00 therefore fails.
The
Claimant’s claim for interest at 10% per annum is not supported by a proven
judgment debt or a separately established contractual or statutory entitlement
to pre-judgment interest. That relief fails.
THE COUNTERCLAIM
38.
The law is settled that a counter-claim is a separate, independent and a distinct
action and a counter-claimant like all other claimants in an action must prove
his case against the person counter-claimed see IJUH V. SONGO & ORS (2025)
LPELR-82078(CA) (PP 44 - 44 PARAS B - C). The Defendant’s counterclaim is a
distinct claim and must be considered independently. The Defendant, as
counterclaimant, bears the burden of proving each relief by credible evidence.
The
Court has considered the counterclaim separately from the Claimant’s claims.
The
declaration that the Claimant’s repeated unauthorised absence amounted to
constructive repudiation is not granted in the precise form sought. A finding
that conduct amounted to misconduct justifying summary termination does not
automatically establish every legal consequence asserted under the label
“constructive repudiation”. The Court has treated the alleged absences as a
contractual disciplinary issue and has not found a sufficient basis to make the
broader declaration as pleaded.
The
counterclaim for ?3,500,000.00 fails for the
reasons given above: the Defendant has not established that clause 11.3 in
Exhibit C1, made the amount recoverable in the circumstances of a termination
initiated by the Defendant.
39.
The Defendant claims special damages described as “One Hundred and Forty-Six
Thousand, Five Hundred and Twenty Thousand US Dollars ($146.520)” or its naira
equivalent. The description of the amount is uncertain on the face of the
counterclaim. In addition, query letters, attendance records and email trails
may prove that absences occurred or caused operational inconvenience, but they
do not by themselves quantify a particular financial loss. The Defendant must
establish the specific transactions or losses, the causal connection between
each loss and the breach, the calculation of the amount, and the documentary
basis for that calculation.
40.
The principle in UNION BANK OF NIGERIA PLC V. ALHAJI ADAMS AJABULE & ANOR.
(2011) 18 NWLR (PT. 1278) 152 requires strict proof of special damages. From
the evidence before the Court, the Defendant has not shown a reliable
calculation or proof supporting the pleaded dollar amount. The claim for
special damages fails.
The
Defendant’s claim for ?5,000,000.00 general damages
also fails. The counterclaim does not, as described, establish a distinct
recoverable loss justifying that award in addition to the special damages
claimed. Nor is general damages a penalty to be imposed merely because an
employee committed misconduct.
41.
The Defendant seeks ?10,000,000.00 as
costs/professional fees. Such a claim is not automatically recoverable merely
because a party retained counsel or incurred litigation expenses. The party
claiming it must provide a proper evidential and legal basis for shifting that
liability to the opposing party. There is no sufficient evidence proving the
amount and its recoverability. This head of the counterclaim fails. The costs
of the proceedings themselves remain within the Court’s discretion.
The
counterclaim for pre-judgment interest fails because the principal monetary
claims upon which it depends have not been proved. Post-judgment interest
likewise has no judgment debt to attach to.
For
the reasons stated above, this Court makes the following orders:
1.
The Claimant’s first relief, seeking a declaration that his employment was
unjustly and wrongfully terminated on 25 July 2022, is dismissed on the finding
that the Defendant established a contractual basis for summary termination.
2.
The Claimant’s second relief succeeds to the limited extent that the Defendant
has not established, on the contractual wording and evidence described in the
supplied draft, a presently enforceable obligation requiring the Claimant to
refund ?3,500,000.00 in the circumstances of this
case.
3.
The Claimant’s relief for an order compelling the Defendant to authorise
release of his pension benefits from Sigma Pension is dismissed for want of
sufficient proof that the Defendant unlawfully withheld or obstructed access to
those benefits.
4.
The Claimant’s claim for ?3,320,000.00 special damages
is dismissed for want of strict proof.
5.
The Claimant’s claim for ?150,000,000.00 general
damages is dismissed.
6.
The Claimant’s claim for interest at 10% per annum is dismissed.
7.
The Defendant’s counterclaim for a declaration that the Claimant’s conduct constituted
constructive repudiation, in the precise form pleaded, is dismissed.
8.
The Defendant’s counterclaim for ?3,500,000.00
as trainer retainership fee is dismissed.
9.
The Defendant’s counterclaim for the dollar amount pleaded as special damages,
or its naira equivalent, is dismissed for uncertainty in the amount pleaded and
want of strict proof.
10.
The Defendant’s counterclaim for ?5,000,000.00
general damages is dismissed.
11.
The Defendant’s counterclaim for ?10,000,000.00
professional fees is dismissed.
12.
The Defendant’s claims for pre-judgment and post-judgment interest are
dismissed.
In
view of the mixed outcome, each party shall bear its own costs.
Judgment
is entered accordingly.
HON. JUSTICE M. A. HAMZA
JUDGE
Note:
This is the transcription of all 23 pages of the uploaded judgment. I have
retained the wording as it appears in the scanned document, including apparent
spelling, grammatical and numerical inconsistencies rather than silently
changing the court's text.